Multilevel regression with poststratification

Multilevel regression with poststratification (MRP) is a statistical technique used for correcting model estimates for known differences between a sample population (the population of the data one has), and a target population (a population one wishes to estimate for).

The poststratification refers to the process of adjusting the estimates, essentially a weighted average of estimates from all possible combinations of attributes (for example age and sex). Each combination is sometimes called a "cell". The multilevel regression is the use of a multilevel model to smooth noisy estimates in the cells with too little data by using overall or nearby averages.

One application is estimating preferences in sub-regions (e.g., states, individual constituencies) based on individual-level survey data gathered at other levels of aggregation (e.g., national surveys).[1]

Mathematical formulation

Following the MRP model description,[2] assume represents single outcome measurement and the population mean value of , , is the target parameter of interest. In the underlying population, each individual, , belongs to one of poststratification cells characterized by a unique set of covariates. The multilevel regression with poststratification model involves the following pair of steps:

MRP step 1 (multilevel regression): The multilevel regression model specifies a linear predictor for the mean , or the logit transform of the mean in the case of a binary outcome, in poststratification cell ,

where is the outcome measurement for respondent in cell , is the fixed intercept, is the unique covariate vector for cell , is a vector of regression coefficients (fixed effects), is the varying coefficient (random effect), maps the cell index to the corresponding category index of variable . All varying coefficients are exchangeable batches with independent normal prior distributions .

MRP step 2: poststratification: The poststratification (PS) estimate for the population parameter of interest is where is the estimated outcome of interest for poststratification cell and is the size of the -th poststratification cell in the population. Estimates at any subpopulation level are similarly derived where is the subset of all poststratification cells that comprise .

The technique and its advantages

The technique essentially involves using data from, for example, censuses relating to various types of people corresponding to different characteristics (e.g., age, race), in a first step to estimate the relationship between those types and individual preferences (i.e., multi-level regression of the dataset). This relationship is then used in a second step to estimate the sub-regional preference based on the number of people having each type/characteristic in that sub-region (a process known as "poststratification").[3] In this way the need to perform surveys at sub-regional level, which can be expensive and impractical in an area (e.g., a country) with many sub-regions (e.g. counties, ridings, or states), is avoided. It also avoids issues with consistency of survey when comparing different surveys performed in different areas.[4][1] Additionally, it allows the estimating of preference within a specific locality based on a survey taken across a wider area that includes relatively few people from the locality in question, or where the sample may be highly unrepresentative.[5]

History

The technique was originally developed by Gelman and T. Little in 1997,[6] building upon ideas of Fay and Herriot[7] and R. Little.[8] It was subsequently expanded on by Park, Gelman, and Bafumi in 2004 and 2006. It was proposed for use in estimating US-state-level voter preference by Lax and Philips in 2009. Warshaw and Rodden subsequently proposed it for use in estimating district-level public opinion in 2012.[1] Later, Wang et al.[9] used survey data of Xbox users to predict the outcome of the 2012 US presidential election. The Xbox gamers were 65% 18- to 29-year-olds and 93% male, while the electorate as a whole was 19% 18- to 29-year-olds and 47% male. Even though the original data was highly biased, after multilevel regression with poststratification the authors were able to get estimates that agreed with those coming from polls using large amounts of random and representative data. Since then it has also been proposed for use in the field of epidemiology.[5]

YouGov used the technique to successfully predict the overall outcome of the 2017 UK general election,[10] correctly predicting the result in 93% of constituencies.[11] In the 2019 and 2024 elections other pollsters used MRP including Survation [12] and Ipsos.[13]

Limitations and extensions

MRP can be extended to estimating the change of opinion over time[4] and when used to predict elections works best when used relatively close to the polling date, after nominations have closed.[14]

Both the "multilevel regression" and "poststratification" ideas of MRP can be generalized. Multilevel regression can be replaced by nonparametric regression[15] or regularized prediction, and poststratification can be generalized to allow for non-census variables, i.e. poststratification totals that are estimated rather than being known.[16]

References

  1. ^ a b c Buttice, Matthew K.; Highton, Benjamin (Autumn 2013). "How Does Multilevel Regression and Poststratification Perform with Conventional National Surveys?" (PDF). Political Analysis. 21 (4): 449–451. doi:10.1093/pan/mpt017. JSTOR 24572674.
  2. ^ Downes, Marnie Downes; at al. (August 2018). "Multilevel Regression and Poststratification: A Modeling Approach to Estimating Population Quantities From Highly Selected Survey Samples". American Journal of Epidemiology. 187 (8): 1780–1790. doi:10.1093/aje/kwy070.
  3. ^ "What is MRP?". Survation.com. Survation. 5 November 2018. Retrieved 31 October 2019.
  4. ^ a b Gelman, Andrew; Lax, Jeffrey; Phillips, Justin; Gabry, Jonah; Trangucci, Robert (28 August 2018). "Using Multilevel Regression and Poststratification to Estimate Dynamic Public Opinion" (PDF): 1–3. Retrieved 31 October 2019. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  5. ^ a b Downes, Marnie; Gurrin, Lyle C.; English, Dallas R.; Pirkis, Jane; Currier, Diane; Spital, Matthew J.; Carlin, John B. (9 April 2018). "Multilevel Regression and Poststratification: A Modeling Approach to Estimating Population Quantities From Highly Selected Survey Samples". American Journal of Epidemiology. 179 (8): 187. Retrieved 31 October 2019.
  6. ^ Gelman, Andrew; Little, Thomas (1997). "Poststratification into many categories using hierarchical logistic regression". Survey Methodology. 23: 127–135.
  7. ^ Fay, Robert; Herriot, Roger (1979). "Estimates of income for small places: An application of James-Stein procedures to census data". Journal of the American Statistical Association. 74 (423): 1001–1012. doi:10.1080/01621459.1979.10482505. JSTOR 2286322.
  8. ^ Little, Roderick (1993). "Post-stratification: A modeler's perspective". Journal of the American Statistical Association. 88 (423): 1001–1012. doi:10.1080/01621459.1993.10476368. JSTOR 2290792.
  9. ^ Wang, Wei; Rothschild, David; Goel, Sharad; Gelman, Andrew (2015). "Forecasting elections with non-representative polls" (PDF). International Journal of Forecasting. 31 (3): 980–991. doi:10.1016/j.ijforecast.2014.06.001.
  10. ^ Revell, Timothy (9 June 2017). "How YouGov's experimental poll correctly called the UK election". New Scientist. Retrieved 31 October 2019.
  11. ^ Cohen, Daniel (27 September 2019). "'I've never known voters be so promiscuous': the pollsters working to predict the next UK election". The Guardian. Retrieved 31 October 2019.
  12. ^ Survation 2019 https://www.survation.com/2019-general-election-mrp-predictions-survation-and-dr-chris-hanretty/
  13. ^ Ipsos 2024 https://www.ipsos.com/en-uk/uk-opinion-polls/ipsos-election-mrp
  14. ^ James, William; MacLellan, Kylie (15 October 2019). "A question of trust: British pollsters battle to call looming election". Reuters. Retrieved 31 October 2019.
  15. ^ Bisbee, James (2019). "BARP: Improving Mister P Using Bayesian Additive Regression Trees". American Political Science Review. 113 (4): 1060–1065. doi:10.1017/S0003055419000480. S2CID 201385400.
  16. ^ Gelman, Andrew (28 October 2018). "MRP (or RPP) with non-census variables". Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science.

Read other articles:

Хоровое окно церкви Святой Марии во Франкфурте-на-Одере (около 1360-ых годов). Красные евреи на берегу реки Самбатион Красные евреи (нем. Rote Juden) — легендарный еврейский народ, который упоминается в фольклорных источниках средневековой Германии. Вера в существование к�...

 

فيصل بن خالد بن سلطان بن عبد العزيز آل سعود العاهل سلمان بن عبد العزيز آل سعود مشعل بن عبد الله بن عبد العزيز بن مساعد آل سعود   أمير منطقة الحدود الشمالية . تولى المنصب22 أبريل 2017 العاهل سلمان بن عبد العزيز آل سعود مستشار ب الديوان الملكي تولى المنصب2016 العاهل سلمان بن عبد ا...

 

Region of Massachusetts, United States 42°20′N 72°50′W / 42.333°N 72.833°W / 42.333; -72.833 This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article's tone or style may not reflect the encyclopedic tone used on Wikipedia. See Wikipedia's guide to writing better articles for suggestions. (May 2015) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Th...

Bü 181 Bestmann A restored Bü 181 performing at the Shoreham Airshow 2012 Role trainerType of aircraft Manufacturer Bücker First flight February 1939 Primary users LuftwaffeCzechoslovakia Egypt Sweden Number built 3,400 The Bücker Bü 181 Bestmann is a twin-seat single-engine aerobatic monoplane trainer aircraft designed and built by the German aviation company Bücker Flugzeugbau. It was extensively operated by the Luftwaffe throughout the Second World War. The Bü 181 was named Be...

 

Les Murray nel 2014 Les Murray, ufficialmente Leslie Allan Murray (Nabiac, 17 ottobre 1938 – Taree, 29 aprile 2019), è stato un poeta e scrittore australiano. Indice 1 Biografia 2 Opere tradotte in italiano 2.1 Poesia 2.2 Romanzi in versi 2.3 Saggi 3 Onorificenze 4 Note 5 Altri progetti 6 Collegamenti esterni Biografia Nato a Nabiac, Nuovo Galles del Sud, nel 1938, trascorre la sua infanzia in povertà nella fattoria dei nonni nel distretto di Bunyah[1]. Rimasto orfano della madre ...

 

Kolkata Municipal Corporation in West Bengal, IndiaWard No. 100Kolkata Municipal CorporationInteractive Map Outlining Ward No. 100Ward No. 100Location in KolkataCoordinates (dms): 22°28′26″N 88°22′18″E / 22.473833°N 88.371694°E / 22.473833; 88.371694Country IndiaStateWest BengalCityKolkataNeighbourhoodGaria (Ramgarh-Naktala-Laxmi Narayan Colony)ReservationOpenParliamentary constituencyJadavpurAssembly constituencyTollyganjBorough10Population ...

American soccer player Erik Hurtado Hurtado playing with the Vancouver Whitecaps FCPersonal informationFull name Erik HurtadoDate of birth (1990-11-15) November 15, 1990 (age 33)Place of birth Fredericksburg, Virginia, United StatesHeight 5 ft 10 in (1.78 m)Position(s) ForwardYouth career2007–2009 Westside MetrosCollege careerYears Team Apps (Gls)2009–2012 Santa Clara Broncos 77 (33)Senior career*Years Team Apps (Gls)2011–2012 Portland Timbers U23s 18 (14)2013–2018...

 

Lake in the United States of America United States historic placeLittle Salt SpringU.S. National Register of Historic Places Little Salt Spring in November 2006Show map of FloridaShow map of the United StatesLocationNorth Port, Florida, U.S.Coordinates27°4′29″N 82°14′0″W / 27.07472°N 82.23333°W / 27.07472; -82.23333NRHP reference No.79000692[1]Added to NRHPJuly 10, 1979 Little Salt Spring is an archaeological and paleontological site in No...

 

Disambiguazione – Se stai cercando la cittadina omonima in Sudafrica, vedi Ermelo (Sudafrica). Questa voce sull'argomento centri abitati dei Paesi Bassi è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Ermelocomune Ermelo – Veduta LocalizzazioneStato Paesi Bassi Provincia Gheldria AmministrazioneCapoluogoErmelo TerritorioCoordinatedel capoluogo52°18′00″N 5°37′59.88″E / &#x...

MI Darul Ulum Beraim merupakan satuan pendidikan dasar berjenis Madrasah ibtidaiah yang berada di bawah naungan Yayasan Al-Ma'arif Beraim. Saat ini MI Darul Ulum Beraim dikepalai Anwar Musaddad, M.Pd. Artikel ini tidak memiliki referensi atau sumber tepercaya sehingga isinya tidak bisa dipastikan. Tolong bantu perbaiki artikel ini dengan menambahkan referensi yang layak. Tulisan tanpa sumber dapat dipertanyakan dan dihapus sewaktu-waktu.Cari sumber: MI Darul Ulum – berita...

 

1983 novel by Allen Drury Decision US first editionAuthorAllen DruryCountryUnited StatesLanguageEnglishGenrePolitical novelPublisherDoubledayPublication dateAugust 1983Media typePrint (hardcover & paperback)Pages486ISBN0-385-18832-3 Decision is a 1983 political novel by Allen Drury which follows a newly appointed Supreme Court Justice as he is faced with the most difficult decision of his life. It is a standalone work set in a different fictional timeline from Drury's 1959 novel Advi...

 

Pemandangan udara Šakiai, menampilkan Balai Kota Šakiai Šakiai (pengucapanⓘ, bahasa Polandia: Szaki) adalah sebuah kota di Kabupaten Marijampolė, Lituania. Kota tersebut berjarak 65 km (40 mi) dari barat Kaunas. Sejarah Šakiai adalah tempat lahir dari filantropis Zionis awal Isaac Leib Goldberg pada 1860.[1] Hubungan internasional Lihat pula: Daftar kota kembar dan kota bersaudara di Lituania Kota kembar — Kota bersaudara Šakiai adalah kembaran dari: Gołdap, P...

Place in Andalusia, SpainVillarrasa FlagSealCountrySpainAutonomous communityAndalusiaProvinceHuelvaArea • Total72 km2 (28 sq mi)Elevation75 m (246 ft)Population (2018)[1] • Total2,152 • Density30/km2 (77/sq mi)Time zoneUTC+1 (CET) • Summer (DST)UTC+2 (CEST)Websitehttp://www.villarrasa.es/es/ Map of Villarrasa, Huelva Villarrasa is a town and municipality located in the province of Huelva, Spain. Accordi...

 

For other places with similar names, see Xinhua District. DistrictSinhua 新化區Shinka; Sin-HuaDistrictJapanese-era Town Government HallSinhua District in Tainan CityLocationTainan, TaiwanArea • Total62 km2 (24 sq mi)Population (May 2022) • Total42,514 • Density690/km2 (1,800/sq mi)Websiteweb.tainan.gov.tw/sinhua_en/ Sinhua District Office Shinhua Station of Shing Nan Bus Co. Sinhua DistrictChinese新化區TranscriptionsStandard M...

 

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Posada (homonymie). Bataille de Posada L'armée de Charles Robert d'Anjou prise en embuscade par l'armée de Basarab à Posada, d'après la Chronique enluminée de Vienne Informations générales Date 9 - 12 novembre 1330 Lieu Transylvanie Issue victoire pour la Valachie Belligérants Valachie Hongrie Commandants Basarab Ier le Fondateur (Basarab Întemeitorul) Charles Ier Robert d'Anjou Forces en présence 10 000 Valaques 30 000 Hongrois Pertes mi...

Pirate Charlotte de BerryBornEnglandDiedCoast of AfricaPiratical careerNicknameDick, Captain RudolphTypePirateAllegiancePirateRankCaptain Charlotte de Berry[a] was allegedly a female pirate captain. Authenticity The earliest known reference to Charlotte de Berry comes from publisher Edward Lloyd's 1836 “penny dreadful” called History of the Pirates. Lloyd was known for producing other similar compilations of shocking and gory tales, often plagiarized.[2] There is no eviden...

 

Adresse gamekult.com Commercial Oui Publicité Oui Type de site Média vidéoludique Langue Français Inscription Payante Nombre d'inscrits 12 200 abonnés (février 2022) Siège social Boulogne-Billancourt France Propriétaire Reworld Media Créé par Kévin KuipersClément Apap Lancement 1er décembre 2000 État actuel En activité modifier  Gamekult est un site web français spécialisé dans le jeu vidéo fondé par Kévin Kuipers et Clément Apap, lancé en décembre 2000...

 

Parlement de Côte d'Ivoire Armoiries de la Côte d'Ivoire.Présentation Type Bicaméral Chambres Assemblée nationaleSénat Création 1959 Lieu Abidjan, Le Plateau (Assemblée nationale)Yamoussoukro (Sénat) Durée du mandat 5 ans Présidence Assemblée nationale Adama Bictogo (RHDP) Élection 7 juin 2022 Sénat Jeannot Ahoussou-Kouadio (RHDP) Élection 5 avril 2018 Structure Membres 354 :255 députés99 sénateurs Données clésDonnées clésÉlection Système électoral(Ass...

マット・モロイMatt Molloy 2000年3月、所有するパブのセッションで演奏するマット・モロイ基本情報生誕 (1947-01-12) 1947年1月12日(77歳)出身地 アイルランド・ロスコモン県 バラーアデリーンジャンル アイルランド音楽、ケルト音楽職業 ミュージシャン担当楽器 フルート共同作業者 ボシー・バンドプランクシティチーフタンズトミー・ピープルズポール・ブレイディ公式�...

 

Herzeele Vue de l'église d'Herzeele. Blason Administration Pays France Région Hauts-de-France Département Nord Arrondissement Dunkerque Intercommunalité Communauté de communes des Hauts de Flandre Maire Mandat Stéphane Francke 2020-2026 Code postal 59470 Code commune 59305 Démographie Gentilé Herzeelois Populationmunicipale 1 634 hab. (2021 ) Densité 95 hab./km2 Géographie Coordonnées 50° 53′ 14″ nord, 2° 32′ 03″ est Altitude ...