Lenczyk played youth soccer for McLean Rockets of the Region 1 Premier League.[5] She also played high school soccer for Langley High School. The Washington Post named Lenczyk its All-Met high school player of the year in 2007.[6]
College career
Lenczyk played for the Virginia Cavailers of the University of Virginia from 2007 to 2010.[7] In the 2010 season, her 12 goals tied with Sinead Farrelly for the team's leading goalscorer. As of 2022[update], Lenczyk was tied for eighth all-time in career goals scored with the Cavaliers (36).[8]
Atlanta Beat selected Lenczyk with the 14th pick in the 2011 WPS Draft.[4] In her professional debut, she scored the match-winning goal against defending champions Sky Blue FC ina 1–0 victory.[10] She made 14 appearances for the Beat, scoring two goals and being credited with one assist.[11]
Lenczyk reunited with Philadelphia Independence coach Paul Riley as part of a "superteam" friendly against D.C. United Women. Riley's team won 1–0 on a goal by Lenczyk.[13]
On February 7, 2013, Sky Blue FC selected Lenczyk with the 29th pick in the 2013 NWSL Supplemental Draft.[14] While Sky Blue coach Jim Gabarra suggested in February 2013 that Lenczyk would likely play for the team,[15] she did not appear in a match for Sky Blue, and the right to sign her to a contract had not yet been exercised by the time of the 2014 NWSL Expansion Draft.[16]