Manchester Airport plc v Dutton

Manchester Airport plc v Dutton
CourtCourt of Appeal
Citations[1999] EWCA Civ 844, [2000] QB 133
Court membership
Judges sittingLaws LJ
Kennedy LJ
Chadwick LJ
Case opinions
Held, per Laws LJ: The court uses the contract to determine the control that arises from the contract. It then couples that with the right of occupation and then proceeds to grant relief as would vindicate licensee's rights of occupation arising out of the contract.
ConcurrenceKennedy LJ
DissentChadwick LJ
Keywords
Licence; right of licensee to occupy; building works; Trust technically prohibited from alienating title; environmental protesters

Manchester Airport plc v Dutton [1999] EWCA 844 is an English land law case, concerning licences in land. It confirmed the court will attach to licences, even where narrowly drawn to avoid giving away title, a right to occupy provided it meets with the clear commercial purposes of the contract. This means those third parties, in this case protestors, who interfered with such rights must be removed.

Facts

A second runway was being built and trees had to go on National Trust land. The National Trust gave Manchester Airport plc authority to let subcontractors enter. Mr Dutton and environmental protestors tried to stop the work in protest, and occupied the land. Manchester Airport plc had not put any people on site yet, but still claimed an injunction under Order 113 of the Rules of the Supreme Court for their removal.

Judgment

Laws LJ held that although the licensee could remove the protestors, ejectment (court bailiffs to assist) under settled law could only be claimed by someone with title or an estate in land. Also, the licensee (the Airport) was not in occupation, and did not have title, so the court could not grant any of the other possessory remedies (in trespass and nuisance).

But given that the licensee had brought a claim in possession, the court would first consider the extent of licensee's actual or right to occupation arising out of any term of the licence contract. Then the court would consider any element of control arising out of the licence contract. Then the court would give such remedies as would vindicate the licensee's rights under the licence contract.

But the licensee must first bring its claim under CPR 55 (then Ord 113) possession proceedings. That is the first step. The court does not then give possession back to the licensee (as licensee had no possession that was disturbed in the first place). The licensee was never entitled to possession only mere occupation. Indeed, the licensee could never obtain possession as National Trust was prohibited from alienating any of its land in possession.

The court gave relief as would vindicate the construction contract. Such relief in this case included an injunction to remove the trespassers from the trees, possibly a (costs) award for the actual removal and other (mainly their legal advocates') costs (to be determined later) and an injunction that would prevent the protesters return.

Relief is given not to put licensee in possession but to vindicate (uphold) such rights of occupation as are given by the contract. The court uses the contract to determine the control that arises from the contract. It then couples that with the right of occupation and then proceeds to grant relief as would vindicate licensee's rights of occupation arising out of the contract.

Kennedy LJ concurred.

Chadwick LJ dissented. ‘In the latter case (which is this case) the plaintiff must succeed by the strength of his title, not on the weakness (or lack) of any title in the defendant.’[1]

See also

Notes

  1. ^ [2000] QB 133, 146-7

References

Read other articles:

Stone Cold Steve Austin

Steve Austin beralih ke halaman ini. Untuk other people with similar names, lihat Steve Austin (disambiguasi). Stone Cold Steve AustinStone Cold Steve Austin di San Diego Comic-Con 2010 .LahirSteven James Anderson18 Desember 1964 (umur 59)Austin, Texas, U.S.PekerjaanKepribadian mediaaktorproduserpegulat profesionalTahun aktif1989–2003, 2022 (gulat)1999–sekarang (lainnya)Suami/istriKathryn Burrhus ​ ​(m. 1990; c. 1992)​Jeanie Clarke...

 

سلاح الدروع الملكي الأردني

سلاح الدروع الملكي الأردني الدولة  الأردن الإنشاء 1952 النوع مناورة جزء من القوات البرية الملكية الأردنية تعديل مصدري - تعديل   سلاح الدروع الملكي الأردني هو أحد تشكيلات القوات البرية الملكية الأردنية التي تُشكل جزءاً من الجيش العربي. تأسس السلاح فعلياً في 1948؛ حيث استخ...

 

دوري كازاخستان الممتاز 2011

دوري كازاخستان الممتاز 2011 تفاصيل الموسم دوري كازاخستان الممتاز  النسخة 20  البلد كازاخستان  المنظم اتحاد كازاخستان لكرة القدم  البطل نادي شاختار قراغندي  مباريات ملعوبة 192   عدد المشاركين 12   دوري كازاخستان الممتاز 2010  دوري كازاخستان الممتاز 2012  تعدي�...

Passive autocatalytic recombiner

Passive autocatalytic recombiner Passive autocatalytic recombiner (PAR) is a device that removes hydrogen from the containment of a nuclear power plant during an accident. Its purpose is to prevent hydrogen explosions. Recombiners come into action spontaneously as soon as the hydrogen concentration increases. They are passive devices because their operation does not require external energy.[1] Hydrogen may be generated in a nuclear accident if the reactor fuel overheats and zirconium ...

 

D'Academy Asia (Musim 2)

D'Academy AsiaMusim 2Penayangan23 Oktober 2016 – 29 Desember 2016JuriHetty Koes Endang Hendro Saky DJ Daffy Eddy Misuari Hans Anuar Zul 2BY2 Pak Ngah Mayuni Omar Sukree Mamagh Kerry The Halabala Jose Manuel Didinho MarcalPembawa acaraRamzi Rina Nose Irfan Hakim Andhika PratamaSaluranIndosiarPeserta36Lokasi finalStudio 5 IndosiarPemenangWeni WahyuniAsalIndonesiaLagu kemenanganEngkaulah TakdirkuGenreDangdutJuara duaNurafni Jamal Rani (Runner-Up) Irsya Cendikiawan (Runner-Up Kedua)Kronologi◀...

 

Universitas Kristen Indonesia

Universitas Kristen IndonesiaLambang Universitas Kristen IndonesiaMotoMelayani, Bukan DilayaniMoto dalam bahasa InggrisTo serve, not to be servedJenisUniversitas swastaDidirikan15 Oktober 1953Afiliasi keagamaanProtestanRektorDr. Dhaniswara K. Harjono, S.H., M.H., MBA.AlamatJl. Mayjen Sutoyo No. 2, Cawang, Jakarta TimurJl. Diponegoro No. 84-86, Jakarta Timur, Indonesia QV2C+MR Cawang, Kota Jakarta Timur, Daerah Khusus Ibukota JakartaKampusUrban: Kampus Diponegoro, Kampus CawangWarnaBiru, ...

Modena Football Club 2014-2015

Voce principale: Modena Football Club. Modena Football ClubStagione 2014-2015Sport calcio Squadra Modena Allenatore Walter Alfredo Novellino (fino alla 28ª giornata), poi Mauro Melotti All. in seconda Giuseppe De Gradi (fino alla 28ª giornata), poi Simone Pavan Presidente Antonio Caliendo Serie B18º posto Coppa ItaliaQuarto turno Maggiori presenzeCampionato: Granoche (41+2) Miglior marcatoreCampionato: Granoche (19+1) StadioAlberto Braglia (21.151) Abbonati3 621[1] Maggior nu...

 

العلاقات السنغافورية الفرنسية

العلاقات السنغافورية الفرنسية سنغافورة فرنسا   سنغافورة   فرنسا تعديل مصدري - تعديل   العلاقات السنغافورية الفرنسية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين سنغافورة وفرنسا.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولتين: وجه الم...

 

Religious socialism

Form of socialism based on religious values Part of a series onSocialism HistoryOutline Development Age of the Enlightenment French Revolution Revolutions of 1848 Socialist calculation debate Socialist economics Ideas Calculation in kind Collective ownership Cooperative Common ownership Critique of political economy Economic democracy Economic planning Equal liberty Equal opportunity Free association Freed market Industrial democracy Input–output model Internationalism Labor-time calculatio...

Mont Sacré d'Oropa

Mont Sacré d'OropaPrésentationType Sacri Monti du Piémont et de LombardiePartie de Sacri Monti du Piémont et de Lombardie, sanctuaire d'OropaCulte CatholicismeDiocèse Diocèse de BielleSurface 154 000 m2 ou 496 000 m2Religion CatholicismePatrimonialité  Patrimoine mondial (2003) Patrimoine mondialIdentifiant 1068-005LocalisationPays ItalieCommune BiellaCoordonnées 45° 37′ 43″ N, 7° 58′ 41″ Emodifier - modifier le code - modifier Wi...

 

Hendra Hidayat

Hendra HidayatPotret resmi, 2023 Wakil Wali Kota Administrasi Jakarta Barat ke-10PetahanaMulai menjabat 21 Maret 2023Wali KotaUus KuswantoPendahuluYani Wahyu PurwokoPenggantiPetahanaWakil Wali Kota Administrasi Jakarta Timur ke-9Masa jabatan4 September 2020 – 21 Maret 2023Wali KotaMuhammad AnwarPendahuluUus KuswantoPenggantiIin Mutmainnah Informasi pribadiLahir19 November 1972 (umur 51)IndonesiaKebangsaanIndonesiaProfesiBirokratSunting kotak info • L �...

 

Hwang Ju-hyun

Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada November 2022. Hwang Ju-hyunInformasi pribadiTanggal lahir 9 Februari 1994 (umur 30)Tempat lahir Korea SelatanPosisi bermain GelandangKarier senior*Tahun Tim Tampil (Gol)2012 Mito HollyHock * Penampilan dan gol di klub senior hanya dihitung dari liga domestik H...

Système d'exploitation

Pour les articles homonymes, voir SE et OS. En informatique, un système d'exploitation (souvent appelé OS — de l'anglais operating system — ou parfois SE — en français) est un ensemble de programmes qui dirige l'utilisation des ressources d'un ordinateur par des logiciels applicatifs[1]. Il reçoit des demandes d'utilisation des ressources de l'ordinateur — ressources de stockage des mémoires (par exemple des accès à la mémoire vive, aux mémoires de masse), ressources de...

 

Карамзина, Екатерина Андреевна

В Википедии есть статьи о других людях с фамилиями Карамзина, Карамзина, Екатерина и Колыванова. Екатерина Андреевна Карамзина Имя при рождении Екатерина Андреевна Колыванова Дата рождения 16 (27) ноября 1780(1780-11-27) Место рождения Ревель Дата смерти 1 (13) сентября 1851(1851-09...

 

Alénya

Peta infrastruktur dan tata guna lahan di Komune Alénya.  = Kawasan perkotaan  = Lahan subur  = Padang rumput  = Lahan pertanaman campuran  = Hutan  = Vegetasi perdu  = Lahan basah  = Anak sungaiAlényaNegaraPrancisArondisemenPerpignanKantonLa Côte RadieuseKode INSEE/pos66002 /  Alénya merupakan sebuah desa berpenduduk 3000 jiwa di departemen Pyrénées-Orientales di Prancis. Desa ini dikelilingi oleh ladang anggur. Aprikot dan peach juga tumbuh...

Bartolomé Esteban Murillo

Spanish Baroque painter (1617–1682) In this Spanish name, the first or paternal surname is Esteban and the second or maternal family name is Murillo. You can help expand this article with text translated from the corresponding article in Spanish. (November 2018) Click [show] for important translation instructions. Machine translation, like DeepL or Google Translate, is a useful starting point for translations, but translators must revise errors as necessary and confirm that the...

 

The Ward, Toronto

Looking south from the centre of St. John's Ward at Albert Street (Dundas Street) and Elizabeth Street. c. 1930 The Ward (formally St. John's Ward) was a neighbourhood in central Toronto, Ontario, Canada, in the 19th and early 20th centuries. Many new immigrants first settled in the neighbourhood; it was at the time widely considered a slum.[1] It was bounded by College, Queen, and Yonge Streets and University Avenue, and was centred on the intersection of Terauley (now Bay) an...

 

المسيحية في جزر الكناري

بازيليكا دي نوسترا سينيورا دي لا كانديلاريا، سانتا كروث دي تينيريفه. المسيحية في جزر الكناري هي ديانة الأغلبية الساحقة من سكان الجزر. وفقًا لمسح CIS Barometer Autonomy لعام 2012 ينتمي أغلبيّة سكان جزر الكناري إلى المذهب الروماني الكاثوليكي والذي يتبعه حوالي 84.9% من سكان الجزر،[1] وم...

جيجي إيوان

جيجي إيوان معلومات شخصية الميلاد 15 سبتمبر 1967 (57 سنة)  غالاتس  الطول 1.85 م (6 قدم 1 بوصة) مركز اللعب مُدَافِع  الجنسية رومانيا  مسيرة الشباب سنوات فريق 1978–1983 CSU Galați المسيرة الاحترافية1 سنوات فريق م. (هـ.) 1983–1991 أوتسيلول غالاتسي 41 (3) 1991–1992 جامعة كلوج 30 (6) 1992–1993 ب�...

 

الخرابة (يريم)

  لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع الخرابة (توضيح). الخرابة (محلة) تقسيم إداري البلد  اليمن المحافظة محافظة إب المديرية مديرية يريم العزلة عزلة بني مسلم القرية قرية الساري السكان التعداد السكاني 2004 السكان 98   • الذكور 56   • الإناث 42   • عدد الأسر 14   • عدد المساكن 17 معلومات...