The congregation was organized in 1839 as Eleventh Presbyterian Church on 4th and Avenue D. The church moved to East 53rd and Madison Avenue in 1872 and changed its name to Memorial Presbyterian Church in commemoration of the Old and New School branches of the denomination.[2][3] The congregation was renamed Madison Avenue Presbyterian Church in 1886.
Phillips Presbyterian Church was organized in 1844 and moved uptown in 1869. In 1872, James Lenox donated a church building, designed in High Victorian Gothic style by R.H. Robertson, on the East 73rd Street site. In 1899, Madison Avenue Presbyterian Church merged with Phillips and the church building was redesigned in a neo-Gothic style by James E. Ware.[2] The current location has an 800-seat sanctuary.[4]
David H. C. Read was pastor of MAPC from 1956 until 1989. During Read's tenure, his sermons were mailed out each Monday as part of a subscription service, and some of his regular radio sermons were broadcast nationally by the National Council of Churches. Read was succeeded by Fred R. Anderson.[8]
^Trump, Fred (2024). All in the Family: The Trumps and How We Got This Way. London: Simon & Schuster. p. 29. ISBN9781398541016. OCLC1453469554. They married the following January at Manhattan's Madison Avenue Presbyterian Church with a British-born minister named George Arthur Buttrick officiating.