William Ruhlmann reviewed the album for Allmusic and wrote that it seemed "...to have been influenced by Henry Mancini's similar success, leading to a more prominent rhythm section and a jazzier feel than one usually associates with Riddle's charts", and that Riddle's "feel for melody was not extinguished by any means but, probably due to his recent experience, his arrangements and (on three tracks) compositions had a far more cinematic flair, which gave them an early-'60s contemporaneity and brought him out of the '50s just as he was moving on to new challenges".[1]
DJ Spooky, in his 2008 book Sound Unbound: Sampling Digital Music and Culture described Riddle's arrangement of "Witchcraft" on this album as a "brain-tickling juxtaposition of reverberating strings, bells, and chimes."[4]
In June 1965, Pickwick Records released seven of the twelve tracks from Love Is a Game of Poker in a ten-track album titled Witchcraft!. Additional tracks came from 1957’s Hey...Let Yourself Go!,* plus a side from a 45 rpm single.**[5]
Side 1
”Witchcraft”
”Along Too Long”
”Red Silk Stockings”
”It’s So Nice to Have a Man Around The House”
”You Fascinate Me So”
Side 2
”Playboy’s Theme”
”Indiscreet”
”I Get Along Without You Very Well”*
”Darn That Dream”*
”Blue Safari”**
An album identical to the Pickwick record--even the liner notes--was released on the Sears label. [6]
Alshire Records
In 1971 Alshire Records issued a budget re-release of ten of the twelve tracks from Love is a Game of Poker re-titled Spectacular Brass!!! Fantastic Reeds!!! and the Magnificent 101 Strings, and credited to "Nelson Riddle with America's Top Soloists." The disc lacked "A Game of Poker" and "You Fascinate Me So."[7]