This section needs expansion with: the rest of the plot--see WP:SPOILER. You can help by adding to it. (December 2013)
Joe Matthews, a professional baseball pitcher from LA on the back end of his career, finds himself and his son (Bobby) in a picturesque community of Amish and Swiss influence after their truck breaks down. Joe is running from the paparazzi, who are constantly bombarding him and his son, about the unsolved murder of Joe's actress wife (Grace) which took place in their home. Joe doesn't want anyone to know where he is nor who he is which leads to the local Sugarcreek Policewoman, Rachel Troyer, becoming suspicious of this stranger in her town. Joe, who can't access his funds back home, needs a place to stay and finds it when he is introduced to three humble elderly Amish women who manage a rundown Amish bed and breakfast called the Sugar Haus Inn. The three Amish women: Bertha, Lydia, and Anna Troyer are the aunts and only living relatives of Rachel Troyer. Joe ends up working for his room and board and helps the women get the Sugar Haus Inn back up and running. Although Rachel Troyer is constantly suspicious of and on guard around Joe, she and he do start to form a relationship, and have to work together to solve the murder of Joe's wife.
Characters in the novel
Main characters
Joe Matthews - (aka Micah Matthias) A former professional baseball pitcher from LA and love interest to Rachel.
Rachel Troyer - A Sugarcreek Police woman, love interest to Joe, and niece to the three Amish women who run the Sugar Haus Inn.
Bobby Matthews - (aka Bobby Matthias) Four-year-old son of Joe Matthews.
Eli Troyer - Elder Amish neighbor and cousin to the Troyer sisters, and humorous mentor to Joe.
Bertha Troyer - Eldest sister of the three Amish women who run the Sugar Haus Inn, and the overseer and decision maker of the Inn.
Lydia Troyer - Middle sister of the three Amish women who run the Sugar Haus Inn, and the main cook for the family.
Anna Troyer - Youngest sister of the three Amish women, and has Down syndrome which helps in becoming good friends with Bobby due to her innocence and child like behavior.
Other characters
Kim Whitfield - A Police Academy graduate who volunteers at the Sugarcreek Police office.
Stephanie Anne Fowler - Pregnant teenager taken in by Rachel Troyer after a domestic abuse situation.
Grace Matthias - The dead actress wife of Joe Matthews.
Henrietta Stiles - Manager for Joe Matthews
Darren Matthias - Joe Matthews' brother.
Dr. Robert Matthias - Joe Matthews' estranged father.