Since its inaugural season in 2014, the American soccer club Indy Eleven, has competed in the second division of American soccer. The team currently competes in the USL Championship after spending its first four years in the defunct North American Soccer League. The following list covers each season of the club's existence, documenting its performance in all competitive competitions.^[1]

Key to competitions

Season	League											Position		Playoffs	USOC	Continental / Other	Average attendance	Top goalscorer(s)
	Div	League	Pld	W	L	D	GF	GA	GD	Pts	PPG	Conf.	Overall					Name	Goals
2014	2	NASL	27	6	12	9	35	46	–11	27	1.00	N/A	9th	DNQ	R4	Ineligible	10,465	Kléberson	8
2015		NASL	30	8	13	9	36	48	–12	33	1.10		9th		R3	DNQ	9,809	Dylan Mares	6
2016		NASL	32	15	7	10	51	33	+18	55	1.72		2nd	RU	R4		8,396	Éamon Zayed	15
2017		NASL	32	7	13	12	39	56	–17	33	1.03		6th	DNQ	R2		8,395	Éamon Zayed	11
2018		USL	34	13	11	10	45	42	+3	49	1.44	7th	16th	R1	R2		10,163	Jack McInerney	10
2019		USLC	34	19	9	6	48	29	+19	63	1.85	3rd	4th	SF	R3		10,734	Tyler Pasher	11
2020		USLC	16	7	7	2	21	19	+2	23	1.44	9th	18th	DNQ	NH		5,167	Tyler Pasher	10
2021		USLC	32	9	15	8	32	47	–15	35	1.09	12th	25th	DNQ	NH		N/A	Manuel Arteaga	10
2022		USLC	34	12	17	5	41	55	–14	41	1.21	9th	19th	DNQ	R2		8,285	Stefano Pinho	11
2023		USLC	34	13	11	10	46	38	+5	49	1.44	6th	11th	R1	R3		9,709	Sebastián Guenzatti	11
2024		USLC	34	14	11	9	49	50	–1	51	1.50	4th	7th	R1	SF		9,795	Augustine Williams	13
Total	–	–	339	123	126	90	443	464	–21	459	1.35	–	–	–	–	–	–	Éamon Zayed	26

^ 1. Avg. attendance include statistics from league matches only.
^ 2. Top goalscorer(s) includes all goals scored in league play, playoffs, U.S. Open Cup, and other competitive matches.