The title song is a dub version of the Jacob Miller song "Baby I Love You So", also produced by Pablo.[3][4] It was released as a 45 rpm single in 1974 on the Mango label (MS-2001), with "Baby I Love You So" as the B-side.[5] A distinctly different mix of the song with vocals and dub can be found on the Jacob Miller and Augustus Pablo album, Who Say Jah No Dread, released in 1992.[6][7][8]
King Tubbys Meets Rockers Uptown was ranked 5th best reggae album and 470th overall in the 1994 book All Time Top 1000 Albums, for which Colin Larkin collected votes from professional musicians and critics, as well as from the record buying public.[18] The album was listed in the 1999 book The Rough Guide: Reggae: 100 Essential CDs.[2] In 2007, The Guardian included it in their list of "1000 Albums to Hear Before You Die".[19] In 2022, Treble magazine named King Tubbys Meets Rockers Uptown one of the ten essential remix albums.[20] It was chosen as the second best reggae album of all time by Mojo magazine in their 2024 list of "The 50 Best Reggae Albums Ever".[21]
Colin Larkin wrote that the album "features the mixing talents of King Tubby let loose on some of Pablo's finest rhythming".[18]Steve Barrow claimed that King Tubbys Meets Rockers Uptown "is the first of all dub CDs to acquire for any collection".[2]The Guardian opined that it "represents a pivotal moment in modern music".[19]MusicHound World wrote: "There were dub albums before King Tubby Meets Rockers Uptown, [...] but none had the impact of this recording".[13]