In 2012, she played with the Ottawa Fury, scoring the final penalty kick in the league championship game to win the league title.[2]
Conheeney suffered a concussion while at Virginia Tech in 2012, and was sidelined for three years.[3][4] In April 2016, she made the opening day roster for Sky Blue FC.[5] She scored the game-winning goal in Sky Blue FC's first game of the 2016 NWSL season.[6]