After his senior year of high school, Reynolds received offers from Navy, Air Force, and Wofford.[3] He also garnered interest from Middle Tennessee State and Vanderbilt.[4] Eventually, he committed to Navy, being impressed by the school's campus and football record.[5]
2012 season
Reynolds throwing during warm-ups of the 2012 Army–Navy Game
Reynolds started his freshman season as the fourth-string quarterback, seeing minor action limited to garbage time. In the fourth game of the season against Air Force, starting quarterback Trey Miller injured his ankle and Reynolds took over, leading the Midshipmen to the win. Afterwards, Reynolds was named the starter,[3] becoming the third freshman in school history to do so,[5] for the final eight games of the season.[2] The Midshipmen went 8–5 in 2012, but lost to the Arizona State Sun Devils in the Kraft Fight Hunger Bowl 62–28.[6]
In the 2015 game against SMU, Reynolds broke the record for the most career rushing touchdowns in FBS history with 78, passing Montee Ball.[10] Later in the season in the Army–Navy Game, Reynolds surpassed Adrian N. Peterson's record for the most rushing touchdowns in NCAA Division I history with 85.[11] He later broke the record for most career total touchdowns with 88 and most rushing yards by a quarterback with 4,559.[12][13] Reynolds also holds other quarterbacking records including the most career rushing attempts and touchdowns, most rushing touchdowns and most rushing touchdowns in a game.[14] He is also the only Navy QB to go 4–0 against Army.[15] Reynolds finished fifth in the Heisman Trophy running, the highest by a service academy player since Navy quarterback Roger Staubach's win in 1963.[16] The 11–2 Midshipmen ended the season with a win over the Pittsburgh Panthers in the Military Bowl, winning 44–28 at home in their own stadium. With this win, Reynolds helped contribute to the first Navy team to ever achieve 11 wins in a season. Also, Reynolds and his senior class picked up their 36th win, which tied the Midshipmen class of 1909.[17]
Reynolds later played in the 2016 East–West Shrine Game, an annual all-star game for seniors, where he made the East team upon switching from quarterback to running back. Even though he did not play in the game due to tightness in his back, he was made a unanimous captain for the East team. Moreover, during the East–West Shrine Game, Reynolds won the Pat Tillman Award, which "is presented to a player who best exemplifies character, intelligence, sportsmanship, and service. The award is about a student-athlete's achievements and conduct, both on and off the field."
On February 28, 2016, the Naval Academy announced that Reynolds would be the last player to wear Number 19. Reynolds joins the list of Roger Staubach (No. 12), Joe Bellino (No. 27), and Napoleon McCallum (No. 30) whose numbers have been retired by the academy.[18]
On September 3, 2016, Reynolds was released by the Ravens during final team cuts and was signed to the practice squad the following day.[25][26] He was promoted to the active roster on December 30 for the final game of the season.[27] However, he was on the inactive list for the game, and became an exclusive rights free agent after the season.[28]
Reynolds signed his exclusive rights free agent one-year contract tender with the Ravens on April 26, 2017.[29] On September 1, 2017, he was waived by the Ravens during final roster cuts.[30]
On May 16, 2018, Reynolds signed with the Seattle Seahawks.[32] He was waived on September 1, 2018 and was re-signed to the practice squad.[33][34] He was promoted to the active roster on September 12.[35] Reynolds made his NFL debut five days later in the Seahawks' 24–17 loss to the Chicago Bears.[36] He was waived on October 13 and was re-signed to the practice squad.[37][38] He was promoted to the active roster on November 24, but was waived three days later and re-signed back to the practice squad.[39][40]
On January 7, 2019, Reynolds signed a reserve/future contract with the Seahawks.[41] He spent the 2019 training camp competing to replace the retiring Doug Baldwin, but lost to John Ursua and was waived on August 31.[42][43]
Seattle Dragons
In October 2019, Reynolds was selected by the Seattle Dragons of the XFL in the 2020 XFL Draft.[44] Dragons head coach Jim Zorn described Reynolds as his "secret weapon", playing receiver, returner, and emergency quarterback.[42]
Reynolds graduated from the United States Naval Academy in May 2016. To dedicate more time to playing professional football, he currently serves in the U.S. Navy Reserve as a lieutenant junior grade. He is a cryptologic warfare officer in the Naval Reserves; he had considered becoming a naval flight officer after the Academy, but elected to enter intelligence after the Navy revised its eligibility policies for the field.[50]
