Sherar debuted for the Blues in the third round of 2022 AFL Women's season 6.[2] On debut, she collected 5 disposals.[3] The following round, she earned herself a rising star nomination after collecting 19 disposals and 4 score involvements against North Melbourne,[4] her performance also earning her coaches votes.[5] After suffering a broken hand, she missed the next two matches to return in round 7.[6]
Arriving at Carlton through the 2021 AFLW Draft, Sherar has impressed from the beginning earning a Rising Star nomination in just her second career game back in season six.
It was a breakout year for Shear in 2023, with the young midfielder earning a maiden nomination in the 2023 All-Australian squad.
Making an appearance in all 10 games in 2023 with the Blues, Sherar ranked fifth in the competition for tackles during the home-and-away season, averaging 8.4 per game.
The midfielder has made a name for herself on the field with her two-way running making her a dangerous prospect to any opposition.