He was born and raised in Seattle, and attended Garfield High School, where several notable musicians have also attended including Jimi Hendrix and Quincy Jones.[2] He started playing drums as a toddler after his parents gifted his older brother a drum set.[3]
Overall went on to study percussion at the Oberlin Conservatory. As an undergraduate at Oberlin, Overall once confronted faculty that endorsed his jazz studies but disapproved of his passion for hip-hop beat making. Also while in college, he experienced manic episodes that required brief hospitalization and led to him being put on medication.[4] His lyrics often document his own mental health struggles, as well as the realities of living as a Black man within the American criminal-justice system.[1]
In 2019, he self-released his debut album, Go Get Ice Cream and Listen to Jazz. He was motivated to release his first solo work after the passing of Roy Hargrove, who appears on a track on the album. The album also features other artists including Arto Lindsay, Theo Croker and Carmen Lundy, among others.[6]
In 2023, Overall was featured in The New York Times’ overview of 21st Century Jazz Music. In the article, fellow drummer and Grammy Award-winner Terri Lyne Carrington highlights Overall as one of her favorite artists of the new millennium. She describes him as a “pre-eminent style bender and blender, successfully juxtaposing genres through his production expertise and use of melodic and harmonic forms that deftly integrate the new with the old.”[7]