In July 2004, the United Hockey League (UHL) awarded a Kansas City franchise to Stephen Franke, co-owner of the UHL's Fort Wayne Komets, for the upcoming 2004–05 season.[2] The Outlaws were coached by Darryl Williams.[3] Joe Bucchino, formerly of the Boston Bruin and New York Ranger organizations, served as General Manager.[4] Richard Adler was the team president, responsible for day-to-day business operations.[5]
Rob Schweyer was named the team's first captain, but when he left the team following an injury, player/assistant coach Jason Ruff received the captain designation. Ruff went on to lead the Outlaws in scoring.[6][7] The Outlaws began their lone season by winning back-to-back home games against cross-state rival Missouri River Otters on October 15 and October 16, 2004, and earning a 5–1 record in the first two weeks. From then on, the team finished last in the Western Division with a record of 28–45–7 (wins, losses and overtime losses).[8][9]
Star players for the Outlaws included Ruff, goaltender Maxime Gingras, winger Joe Seroski, defenseman Matthieu Descoteaux, winger Jimmy Callahan and center Mark Lee. Lee started his professional tenure with the Outlaws, which jump started his career in the American Hockey League and the ECHL.[10]
The team struggled to attract fans as the reported attendance was "around 2,800" per game according to team officials.[11] The team played their final game, an 8–1 win over the Komets on April 10, 2005. Following the finale, it was reported three days later that a local printing company, Superior Color Graphics LLC, had filed a lawsuit for non-payment against the team. The lawsuit was reported to be in totaling $45,777.56.[11] The lawsuit was eventually dismissed. Around this time rumors began to circulate the team would move to Toledo, Ohio, the following season.[12] On April 15, 2005, the team suspended operations and officially folded, leaving Kansas City without a professional hockey team once again.[13]