Carmichael got drafted to the Collingwood Magpies in the 2022 mid-season draft at pick number 9.[1] Carmichael didn't play a game in the AFL until round 17 against the North Melbourne Football Club at the MCG.[2] He got 14 disposals in his debut game. The next round against Adelaide Carmichael kicked his first goal in the AFL.[3] In his third game for Collingwood he was selected as medi-sub and kicked 2 fourth quarter goals to help his team defeat the Essendon Football Club.[4] Josh Carmichael played the next three games but got dropped for Collingwood's 1 point win against Carlton.[5] He got selected as medi-sub in the semi final win against the Fremantle Dockers. He played his first game of 2023 against the Richmond Football Club where he managed to only get 2 disposals.[6]
Before the 2022 preliminary final against Sydney, Carmichael and teammate Beau McCreery got in a car crash on the Monash Freeway going to the Melbourne Airport. They did not get any injuries and McCreery was able to play the final.[7]
In July 2024, Carmichael was medically retired due to ongoing concussion symptoms.[8]
Statistics
Statistics are correct to the end of the 2023 season[9]