Hill was invited to attend the St. John's IceCaps training camp for the 2013–14 season. On the eve of the opening night, he was signed to a one-year AHL contract with the IceCaps on October 5, 2013.[3]
After two seasons with the IceCaps, and unable to secure an AHL contract, Hill returned to the ECHL in signing a one-year deal with the Norfolk Admirals on August 20, 2015.[4]
As a free agent on August 5, 2016, Hill continued in the ECHL, signing a one-year deal with the Toledo Walleye.[5] Following the 2016–17 season, Hill announced his retirement from professional hockey due to a lingering hip injury on September 4, 2017.[6]