In 1972, redistricting weakened Bechtold's chances for reelection, and he was challenged for the nomination by Helen Fix. While it looked initially like Bechtold had secured the nomination, a recount declared Fix the winner by one vote.[2] As a result, Bechtold's time in the legislature ended after three terms.
Following his time in the House, he returned to Cincinnati and private practice. He died on September 6, 1978, of a heart attack.[3]