While playing in the minor leagues with the Louisville Colonels with player-managerJoe McCarthy, Kirke told McCarthy that, as a player, McCarthy did not "look so good" to his fellow ballplayers. McCarthy credited Kirke's remark with inspiring him to quit playing and focus instead on managing.[2] McCarthy would go on to be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame as a manager.
After a long and successful career as both a minor league player and manager, Kirke moved to New Orleans while his son, Judson, played and managed in the minors.[2][3]