Minor controversy arose over the casting of Will Strongheart in the supporting role of Virgil in the film; the actor was known to have a history of criminal domestic violence. Strongheart has attributed his past actions to problems with drugs and alcohol. He said that he regrets such actions, and has reformed since attaining sobriety in 2010.[8]
Plot
The Indian Horse family, including six-year-old Saul and his older brother, retreat in canoes deep into the wild to avoid the authorities after Saul's older brother is left seriously ill by his time in an Indian residential school. Saul resolves never to go to a residential school. His parents have converted to Christianity and believe that their eldest son will go to heaven. When the boy dies, they take him away to be blessed by a priest, leaving Saul with his grandmother deep in the woods. The parents do not return.
Saul and his grandmother stay and camp, but once cold weather starts, his grandmother decides they must continue their trek toward their ancestral lands. After their canoe capsizes, they huddle to stay warm at night; they continue their journey on foot through snow. When his grandmother dies, Saul is discovered by the authorities and forcibly taken to a residential school. There, he meets a boy named Lonnie, who can't speak English. The top official, Father Quinney, and his nun deem Lonnie an unsuitable name and call him Aaron. They forbid the boys to speak their Ojibwe language, beating Lonnie because he knows no English.
In the school, Saul witnesses the nuns and priest instructors abuse the children, and struggles to survive. Father Gaston Leboutilier seems to want to change conditions. He convinces Father Quinney to allow a new outdoor activity, ice hockey. Saul does not meet the age requirement to play, but he convinces Father Leboutilier to give him the job of maintaining the rink in the early morning, which allows him to spend time on the ice.
From watching televised hockey games and practising in the mornings, Saul also begins learning techniques. When one of the school's players is injured, Saul steps forward as a substitute and astounds Father Leboutilier with his talent. Saul declines to join Lonnie's escape attempt, as Saul was looking forward to playing; Lonnie is recaptured and punished.
Saul shows remarkable hockey skills on the school team. When he becomes a teen, the school allows Saul to leave and move into a foster home with an Indigenous family in a mining town, where he can further pursue hockey. Saul joins an all-Indigenous team called the Moose, who travel to games between Indian reserves. He receives the jersey number 13, "for luck". After winning a key game, Saul is treated as a star player in Hockey Night in Canada style, but the team faces racial discrimination and beatings by whites afterwards in a pub.
Saul attracts the attention of the Toronto Monarchs, a feeder team for the Toronto Maple Leafs, but he does not want to leave his friends in the Moose. His team insists he take the offer, and he reluctantly joins the Monarchs. There, he keeps his number 13, which no one else wants due to superstition about the number being unlucky. Initially excelling, he is put off by a racist caricature of him in the newspaper. On the ice, Saul becomes the target of racist slurs from opponents and teammates alike, while the audience throws toy Indian figures onto the ice. He reacts to being fouled several times with violence against other players, and is confined to the penalty box. He is stunned when Father Leboutilier appears one night, professing pride in where hockey has taken Saul, and admitting the abuses in the school were wrong. Father Leboutilier tells Saul that the church is sending him to work in Africa. Leboutilier's appearance causes Saul to have flashbacks to the abuses committed at the school, and he leaves the team.
Taking odd low-level jobs, Saul drifts from place to place between 1979 and 1989. He sees Lonnie in an alley, drinking liquor. Saul also drinks a lot and develops alcoholism. Facing serious health issues after severe damage to his liver, Saul is accepted by the Indigenous rehabilitation centre Rising Dawn. The group therapy leader, seeing how sad and withdrawn Saul is, encourages him to confront the root of his suffering. Saul returns to the now closed school, where it is revealed that he had been sexually molested by Father Leboutilier. He felt betrayed because the priest had also opened hockey to him.
Saul makes a pilgrimage by canoe back to his ancestral lands. After he returns to his foster family, he is happily welcomed by them and his former Moose teammates.
Released to average reviews, Indian Horse was a box-office bomb, garnering only $1.69 million on an $8 million budget. Nonetheless, Indian Horse was the highest-grossing English Canadian film of 2018.[9]
Bill Sheppard and Dean Giammarco (re-recording mixers), Patrick Haskill (sound designer), Gord Hillier (dialogue editor), Maureen Murphy (Foley artist), and Gordon Sproule (mix technician)
