Kevin John Coyne of Country Universe gave the song a B− grade, saying that it "features Strait singing in such an exaggerated twang that the entire proceedings feel more campy than country."[2]
Chart performance
"If You Ain't Lovin'" reached number two for three weeks on the BillboardHot Country Songs chart for Faron Young in 1954.[3]
George Strait's version was a chart topper in 1988, his eighth consecutive single to do so.[4]