Billboard recommended this album to retailers, calling it an "exceptional package" and noting several standout tracks.[1] Editors at AllMusic Guide rated this album three out of five stars, with critic Quint Kik calling Taylor Motown's "greatest enigma" and criticizes the cover versions as bland, but considers the originals stronger due to Taylor's gift for songwriting.[2]
This album underperformed in terms of sales.[3] Canada's RPM certified this album peak at fiftieth on February 13, 1971[4] and in the United States, it reached 198 on the Billboard 200.[5] Additionally, the single "Indiana Wants Me" was a top five hit.[6]