This section needs expansion. You can help by adding to it. (September 2022)
Dwight Garner of The New York Times praised the book, stating that it had "an eye for detail and an inquisitive manner" and "plain, gently simmering prose".[5] Garner stated that in regards to the portions from the mid-20th century to the present, the portions were those he "especially enjoyed".[5]William Grimes, of the same newspaper, stated that the author "handles the cultural politics of black cuisine skillfully".[6]
Davis called the book "engaging, accessible, and valuable", and argued it is a "valuable contribution".[7]
Jennifer Jensen Wallach of the University of North Texas stated that the work is "engaging, readable, and impressive in its chronological scope".[8]
Vanessa Bush of Booklist described the work as a "passionate perspective" that the photographs had "enhance[d]".[9]
Kirkus Reviews criticized the book, and summarized its review by stating that the author "folds into her batter so many weighty ingredients that it fails to rise".[2]