Hans Köchler's Lockerbie trial observer mission

Hans Köchler's Lockerbie trial observer mission stemmed from the dispute between the United Kingdom, the United States, and Libya concerning arrangements for the trial of two Libyans accused of causing the explosion of Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie on 21 December 1988.

The dispute was resolved on the basis of legally binding United Nations Security Council Resolution 1192 of 27 August 1998.[1]

Hans Köchler

UN-nominated observers

UN Security Council resolution 1192 "welcomed" "the initiative for the trial of the two [Libyan] persons charged with the bombing of Pan Am flight 103 ... before a Scottish court sitting in the Netherlands" and "invited" the Secretary-General of the United Nations "to nominate international observers to attend the trial". By a letter dated 28 October 1997, the Permanent Representative of the United Kingdom had informed the Secretary-General "that the United Kingdom would welcome the presence of international observers from the United Nations at the trial of the suspects in the Lockerbie bombing".[2]

In a letter dated 25 April 2000, addressed to the President of the Security Council, Secretary-General Kofi Annan nominated five international observers, one each from the European Union, the League of Arab States, and jointly from the Organization of African Unity and the Non-Aligned Movement, and two from the International Progress Organization, a Vienna-based NGO in consultative status with the United Nations, among them the organisation's president, Hans Köchler, professor at the University of Innsbruck, Austria.[3]

Reports on the trial and appeal

Hans Köchler was the only international observer to submit comprehensive reports on the Lockerbie trial and appeal proceedings to the Secretary-General of the United Nations who, in turn, forwarded them to the Registrar of the Scottish Court in the Netherlands.

Köchler's reports were highly critical of the proceedings and challenged the fairness and impartiality of the High Court of Justiciary. Their publication triggered a large-scale international debate, including in the British House of Commons,[4] about the politicisation of criminal trials in the context of power politics. Köchler had characterised the initial trial verdict of 31 January 2001 (which had led to the acquittal of one of the two accused Libyans) as "inconsistent" and "arbitrary". On the day of the announcement of the appeal verdict (14 March 2002) he described the dismissal of the convicted Libyan national's appeal as a "spectacular miscarriage of justice".[5]

Second Lockerbie appeal

Upon publication on 28 June 2007 of a summary of a report by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission, which took four years to review Abdelbaset al-Megrahi's case and granted him leave for a second appeal against conviction, Köchler issued a statement in which he expressed surprise at the commission's focus and apparent bias in favour of the judicial establishment in Scotland:

"In giving exoneration to the police, prosecutors and forensic staff, I think they show their lack of independence. No officials to be blamed: simply a Maltese shopkeeper."[6]

He called for the full report of the SCCRC to be published, for a full and independent public inquiry into the Lockerbie bombing case and for the proceedings of the Court of Criminal Appeal to be witnessed by international observers.[7]

On 4 July 2007, Köchler wrote to Scottish first minister, Alex Salmond, British foreign secretary, David Miliband, home secretary, Jacqui Smith and minister for Africa, Asia and the UN, Mark Malloch Brown, reiterating his call for a public inquiry into the Lockerbie case and insisting that UN-appointed legal experts (from countries other than the UK, US and Libya) should be involved in such an inquiry.[8]

In the June 2008 edition of the Scottish lawyers' magazine The Firm, Köchler referred to the 'totalitarian' nature of the second Lockerbie appeal process saying it "bears the hallmarks of an 'intelligence operation'."[9][10]

Wide-ranging debate

Köchler's reports as UN-appointed international observer of one of the most controversial criminal trials in British history have led to a global debate on the role of NGO observers in the context of international criminal justice.[11][12]

Through his novel and pro-active interpretation of his assignment as UN-appointed "international observer",[13] he has redefined the role of observers in the context of international criminal justice. His reports have been published as landmark documents of international law in collections such as that of the Peace Palace Library of the International Court of Justice.

His experience as observer of the Lockerbie trial led him to write the book Global Justice or Global Revenge? (2003) in which he describes the challenges faced by international criminal justice under the conditions of power politics and draws general conclusions in terms of the doctrine of international law.

In September 2008, following a meeting organised by the Lockerbie Justice Group at Greshornish House on the Isle of Skye, Köchler and Professor Robert Black called for a new public inquiry into the Lockerbie bombing.[14] Köchler said:

"Irrespective of the outcome of the current appeal, there should be a reinvestigation of the incident by the Scottish authorities. It is extremely frustrating that with regard to such an incident just one person has been presented as the culprit and no further questions asked. Only a child would believe such a story."

During Köchler's visit to Scotland, he met former MP and Lockerbie activist Tam Dalyell, MSP Alex Neil and Iain McKie, father of Scottish policewoman Shirley McKie. On 18 September 2008, he delivered a keynote speech on the "Lockerbie Trial and the Rule of Law" organised by The Firm magazine which was held at the Glasgow Hilton Hotel. Focusing on the public interest immunity certificate deployed by the British government, Köchler said:[15]

"Whether those in public office like it or not, the Lockerbie trial has become a test case for the criminal justice system of Scotland. At the same time, it has become an exemplary case on a global scale – its handling will demonstrate whether a domestic system of criminal justice can resist the dictates of international power politics or simply becomes dysfunctional as soon as "supreme state interests" interfere with the imperatives of justice. (...) The fairness of judicial proceedings is undoubtedly a supreme and permanent public interest. If the rule of law is to be upheld, the requirements of the administration of justice may have to take precedence over public interests of a secondary order – such as a state's momentary foreign policy considerations or commercial and trade interests. The internal stability and international legitimacy of a polity in the long term depend on whether it is able to ensure the supremacy of the law over considerations of power and convenience."

Hans Koechler's two observer reports

IPO documents

United Nations documents

Köchler's publications on Lockerbie

See also

References

  1. ^ "Text of UNSCR 1192 of 1998". United Nations. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  2. ^ "UN Press Release of 30 October 1997, SG/SM/6372". United Nations. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  3. ^ "Nomination of international observers" (PDF). Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  4. ^ "House of Commons debate". I-p-o.org. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  5. ^ "UN monitor decries Lockerbie judgement". BBC News. 14 March 2002. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  6. ^ This could open a can of worms for the entire Scottish justice system Archived 12 July 2007 at the Wayback Machine Glasgow Herald 28 June 2007
  7. ^ "Statement of 29 June 2007". I-p-o.org. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  8. ^ "Call for "full and independent public inquiry into the Lockerbie case"". I-p-o.org. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  9. ^ "UN Observer to the Lockerbie Trial says 'totalitarian' appeal process bears the hallmarks of an "intelligence operation"". Thefirmmagazine.com. Archived from the original on 7 September 2008. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  10. ^ Lockerbie bomber hearing 'flawed' Archived 29 August 2008 at the Wayback Machine
  11. ^ "JI 2005.2 v.1" (PDF). Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  12. ^ See also "The Role of Fair Trial Observers" in: M. P. Scharf, "Errors and Missteps: Key Lessons the Iraqi Special Tribunal Can Learn from the ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL," Case Research Paper Series in Legal Studies, Case School of Law, Sept. 2005, pp. 24ff
  13. ^ "Statement of 9 June 2001". I-p-o.org. Retrieved 5 June 2010.
  14. ^ "Legal experts call for new public inquiry on Lockerbie bomb". The Scotsman. UK. 17 September 2008. Retrieved 17 September 2008.
  15. ^ "Law and Politics in the Lockerbie Case". International Progress Organization. 22 September 2008. Retrieved 22 September 2008.

Further reading

Read other articles:

Formula used to model how air pressure varies with altitude The barometric formula is a formula used to model how the pressure (or density) of the air changes with altitude. Pressure equations See also: Atmospheric pressure Pressure as a function of the height above the sea level There are two equations for computing pressure as a function of height. The first equation is applicable to the standard model of the troposphere in which the temperature is assumed to vary with altitude at a lapse r...

 

Republik NikaraguaRepública de Nicaragua (Spanyol) Bendera Lambang Semboyan: En Dios Confiamos(Indonesia: Pada Tuhan Kami Percaya)Lagu kebangsaan: Himno Nacional de Nicaragua(Indonesia: Himne Nasional Nikaragua)Ibu kota(dan kota terbesar)Managua12°6′N 86°14′W / 12.100°N 86.233°W / 12.100; -86.233Bahasa resmiSpanyolPemerintahanRepublik presidensial• Presiden Daniel Ortega• Wakil Presiden Rosario Murillo LegislatifAsamblea NacionalKemerde...

 

Lukas 17Sebagian Injil Lukas pada Papirus 45, yang ditulis sekitar tahun 250 M.KitabInjil LukasKategoriInjilBagian Alkitab KristenPerjanjian BaruUrutan dalamKitab Kristen3← pasal 16 pasal 18 → Lukas 17 (disingkat Luk 17) adalah pasal ketujuh belas Injil Lukas pada Perjanjian Baru dalam Alkitab Kristen. Disusun oleh Lukas, seorang Kristen yang merupakan teman seperjalanan Rasul Paulus.[1][2] Teks Naskah aslinya ditulis dalam bahasa Yunani. Sejumlah naskah tertua yan...

Kejuaraan Dunia Futsal FIFA 2000(Spanyol) Campeonato Mundial de Fútbol Sala de la FIFA 2000Informasi turnamenTuan rumah GuatemalaJadwalpenyelenggaraan18 November s.d. 3 Desember 2000Jumlahtim peserta16 (dari 6 konfederasi)Tempatpenyelenggaraan2 (di 1 kota)Hasil turnamenJuara Spanyol (gelar ke-1)Tempat kedua BrasilTempat ketiga PortugalTempat keempat RusiaStatistik turnamenJumlahpertandingan40Jumlah gol302 (7,55 per pertandingan)Jumlahpenonton224.038...

 

1885 1893 Élections législatives françaises de 1889 576 députés à la Chambre des députés 22 septembre et 6 octobre 1889 Type d’élection Élections législatives Corps électoral et résultats Inscrits 10 387 330 Votants 7 953 382   76,64 %  0,9 Républicains – Pierre Tirard Liste Union des gauchesRépublicains progressistesRadicauxRadicaux-socialistes Voix 4 867 470 61,2 %   2,6 Députés élus 354 &#...

 

For the former administrative subdivision of Moldova, see Edineț County. Municipality in Edineț District, MoldovaEdinețMunicipality FlagCoat of armsEdinețLocation in MoldovaCoordinates: 48°10′N 27°19′E / 48.167°N 27.317°E / 48.167; 27.317CountryMoldovaDistrictEdineț DistrictEstablished1431Government • MayorConstantin Cojocari (LOC)Area • Total2.2 sq mi (5.7 km2)Elevation758 ft (231 m)Population (2014)&#...

العلاقات التنزانية الليبية تنزانيا ليبيا   تنزانيا   ليبيا تعديل مصدري - تعديل   العلاقات التنزانية الليبية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين تنزانيا وليبيا.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولتين: وجه المقارنة تنز�...

 

Sporting event delegationAustralia at the1932 Summer OlympicsIOC codeAUSNOCAustralian Olympic CommitteeWebsitewww.olympics.com.auin Los AngelesCompetitors13 (9 men, 4 women) in six sportsFlag bearerAndrew CharltonMedalsRanked 10th Gold 3 Silver 1 Bronze 1 Total 5 Summer Olympics appearances (overview)189619001904190819121920192419281932193619481952195619601964196819721976198019841988199219962000200420082012201620202024Other related appearances1906 Intercalated Games ––––  A...

 

EuroLeague season EuroleagueThe Sinan Erdem Dome in Istanbul hosted the Final FourSeason2011–12Duration19 October 2011 – 13 May 2012Number of teams24Regular seasonSeason MVP Andrei KirilenkoFinalsChampions Olympiacos (2nd title)  Runners-up CSKA MoscowThird place FC Barcelona RegalFourth place PanathinaikosFinal Four MVP Vassilis SpanoulisStatistical leadersPoints Bo McCalebb 16.9Rebounds Andrei Kirilenko 7.5Assists Omar Cook 5.7Index Rating Andrei Kirilenko 24.2← 2010–11 20...

Atmospheric pressure laser ionization is an atmospheric pressure ionization method for mass spectrometry (MS). Laser light in the UV range is used to ionize molecules in a resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization (REMPI) process. It is a selective and sensitive ionization method for aromatic and polyaromatic compounds.[1] Atmospheric photoionization is the latest in development of atmospheric ionization methods.[2] Ionization principle APLI Ionization Mechanism: A molecule M ...

 

City in FloridaMarathon, FloridaCityCity of MarathonLocation in Monroe County and the U.S. state of FloridaU.S. Census Bureau map showing city limitsCoordinates: 24°43′35″N 81°2′25″W / 24.72639°N 81.04028°W / 24.72639; -81.04028Country United States of AmericaState FloridaCounty MonroeIncorporated1999Government • TypeCouncil-Manager • MayorRobyn Still • Vice MayorLuis Gonzalez • CouncilmembersLynn L...

 

Sceaux 行政国 フランス地域圏 (Région) イル=ド=フランス地域圏県 (département) オー=ド=セーヌ県郡 (arrondissement) アントニー郡小郡 (canton) 小郡庁所在地INSEEコード 92071郵便番号 92330市長(任期) フィリップ・ローラン(2008年-2014年)自治体間連合 (fr) メトロポール・デュ・グラン・パリ人口動態人口 19,679人(2007年)人口密度 5466人/km2住民の呼称 Scéens地理座標 北緯48度4...

この項目には、一部のコンピュータや閲覧ソフトで表示できない文字が含まれています(詳細)。 数字の大字(だいじ)は、漢数字の一種。通常用いる単純な字形の漢数字(小字)の代わりに同じ音の別の漢字を用いるものである。 概要 壱万円日本銀行券(「壱」が大字) 弐千円日本銀行券(「弐」が大字) 漢数字には「一」「二」「三」と続く小字と、「壱」「�...

 

Bài này không có nguồn tham khảo nào. Mời bạn giúp cải thiện bài bằng cách bổ sung các nguồn tham khảo đáng tin cậy. Các nội dung không có nguồn có thể bị nghi ngờ và xóa bỏ. Nếu bài được dịch từ Wikipedia ngôn ngữ khác thì bạn có thể chép nguồn tham khảo bên đó sang đây. Phó Chủ tịch Hội đồng quốc phòng và an ninh Việt NamQuốc huy Việt NamĐương nhiệmPhạm Minh Chínhtừ 5 tháng ...

 

此條目需要补充更多来源。 (2021年7月4日)请协助補充多方面可靠来源以改善这篇条目,无法查证的内容可能會因為异议提出而被移除。致使用者:请搜索一下条目的标题(来源搜索:美国众议院 — 网页、新闻、书籍、学术、图像),以检查网络上是否存在该主题的更多可靠来源(判定指引)。 美國眾議院 United States House of Representatives第118届美国国会众议院徽章 众议院旗...

Sumoat the 2022 World GamesVenueBoutwell Auditorium Birmingham, United StatesDates9–10 JulyNo. of events8← 2017 The sumo competition at the 2022 World Games took place in July 2022,[1] in Birmingham in United States, at the Boutwell Auditorium; the lightweight, middleweight, and heavyweight events were held on July 9 and the openweight events were held on July 10. Originally scheduled to take place in July 2021, the Games were rescheduled for July 2022 as a result of the...

 

Pinna nobilis Spesimen hidupf Pinna nobilis, di Levanto, Liguria (Italia) Klasifikasi ilmiah Kerajaan: Animalia Filum: Mollusca Kelas: Bivalvia Ordo: Pterioida Famili: Pinnidae Genus: Pinna Spesies: P. nobilis Nama binomial Pinna nobilisLinnaeus, 1758 Sinonim Pinna gigas Chemnitz Pinna nobilis adalah sebuah spesies besar dari kerang Laut Tengah, sebuah moluska bivalve laut dalam Pinnidae. Spesies tersebut dapat memiliki panjang sampai 120 cm (4 ft).[1] Penjelasan Spesi...

 

Second Sikh guru from 1539 to 1552 Guru Angadਗੁਰੂ ਅੰਗਦMiniature painting depiction of Guru AngadPersonalBornLehna(1504-03-31)31 March 1504Matte-di-Sarai (Sarainaga), Sri Muktsar Sahib, PanjabDied29 March 1552(1552-03-29) (aged 47)Khadur Sahib, Tarn Taran district[1]ReligionSikhismSpouseMata KhiviChildrenBaba Dasu (1521–1598) Baba Dattu (1524–1575) Bibi Amro (1529–1601) Bibi Anokhi (1531–1608)Parent(s)Mata Ramo and Baba Pheru MalKnown forStandardising ...

List of events ← 1773 1772 1771 1770 1769 1774 in France → 1775 1776 1777 1778 1779 Decades: 1750s 1760s 1770s 1780s 1790s See also:Other events of 1774History of France  • Timeline  • Years Events from the year 1774 in France Incumbents Monarch – Louis XV (until 10 May),[1] then Louis XVI[2] Events 10 May – Louis XV of France dies,[1] and Louis XVI becomes the new king[2] Louis XVI faces empty treasury di...

 

دوري الدرجة الثانية السعودي الموسم 2001–02 البلد السعودية  الفائز نادي هجر صاعدون نادي هجرنادي الجبلين هابطون نادي العدالةنادي الفيصلي المباريات الملعوبة 112 تعديل مصدري - تعديل   دوري الدرجة الثانية السعودي 2001–02 كان موسم من دوري الدرجة الثانية السعودي، وقد شارك في الد...