In January 2017, Anderson joined the cast of the film Jigsaw, the eighth film in the Saw franchise, playing the role of Eleanor Bonneville.[2] The film was released in October 2017 and grossed $103 million worldwide, but received generally negative reviews from critics.
In June 2017, Anderson was cast as Jackie in the 2018 horror film What Keeps You Alive, alongside her Jigsaw co-star Brittany Allen.[3] The film had its wide release in August 2018, and received positive reviews from critics. Dennis Harvey of Variety magazine wrote: "Anderson is very good in a pocket-size variation on Rosamund Pike's 'Gone Girl' type".[4]
In April 2018, Anderson was cast as Jenna Betancourt, an anti-Purge proponent, in the horror series The Purge. The series is based on the franchise of the same name.[5] The series ran for two seasons, and was cancelled in May 2020.[6]
Anderson starred as Joy in the 2022 horror film Dark Nature, which received a limited theatrical release in North America in May 2023.[7] In March 2023, she was cast as Mary in Return to Silent Hill, the third film in the Silent Hill film series.[8][9]
