Gladys Shields Pyle[1] (October 4, 1890 – March 14, 1989) was an American educator and national record setting female politician during the first score of years post-ratification of Women's Suffrage Amendment to the U. S. Constitution, who set numerous national and state partisan electoral records before the age of 50, including at least a dozen national records related to her 1938 U. S. Senate election. Her most significant national electoral records are:
First female nationally to enter the U S Senate through election (1938) and first to do so in her own right at the age of 48. She ran 5.6% ahead of the second highest vote getter for any statewide office in her state in that election.
First female nationally to run for both governor (1930, won her party primary but was denied the nomination by her state party convention, which was perceived to be solely due to her sex by the South Dakota citizenry and press) and U.S. Senate (1938, elected) and first to do so in her own right. (Nationally, Jeanne Shaheen finally beat this record 70 years later by winning both offices in 2008.)
First female nationally to be elected to both a state constitutional legislative office (1922) and a state constitutional executive office (1926) in any state and first to do so in her own right. Only female nationally to be both the first elected to a state constitutional legislative office and the first to be elected to a state constitutional executive office in any state.
First female nationally to receive more votes cast than had been received by any other statewide candidate since statehood in any state (1928).
Second female nationally to receive both the highest percentage of the vote received of all statewide candidates and most total raw votes received of all statewide candidates in a general election in any state (1928) and first female to do so since ratification of the Suffrage Amendment in any state.
Pyle worked in education from 1912 to 1920.[5][11] After teaching Latin and civics for two years in Huron, she became principal of Wessington's public schools.[12] Gladys, her mother Mamie, and two sisters were very involved in the Women's Suffrage movement and frequently hosted meetings of the local League of Women Voters chapter in their house.[13] Pyle became a lecturer for the league[5] and traveled to Indiana, Iowa, Nebraska, Kansas and Ohio to give speeches and make presentations.[12]
In 1922, she ran for a seat in the South Dakota House of Representatives.[12] After failing to gain the nomination through the Beadle CountyRepublicans, Pyle ran in the Independent ticket primary, which she appeared to lose, but successfully contested the result. In the general election, she was the leading vote getter for the three at large House seats, and was elected on the Independent ticket, along with two Republicans.[12] In 1923, she became first woman member of the state House of Representatives.[14] She was reelected in 1924,[15] and served from 1923 to 1927.[16] In addition to her part-time legislative position, Pyle was also appointed to serve as Deputy Secretary of State of South Dakota.[17]
Secretary of State
In 1926, Pyle was the successful Republican nominee for Secretary of State of South Dakota.[16] She was reelected in 1928, polling more votes than had ever been given any candidate for any office in the state,[18] and served from 1927 to 1931.[19]
In 1930, she was a candidate for the Republican nomination for governor.[20] She won the primary, garnering nearly a third of the vote. Since no candidate received the 35% required under South Dakota law, the contest moved to the Republican Convention, where the delegates would select the nominee from the five candidates on the primary ballot. Pyle led the fourth, and sixth through eleven ballots, increasing her total votes each ballot, except for a significant loss of votes the eighth ballot as she was closing in on the nomination. During the 12th ballot, the Convention Chair suspended the roll call and over three hours later, three male candidates threw their support to Warren E. Green, who had run last in the primary with about 7.5% of the vote and who won the nomination when the roll call resumed. Pyle quickly conceded defeat without rancor or accusation but did not endorse Green until after the filing period for filing as an independent had ended. She later hinted at her disappointment when she indicated she would not seek further partisan political office.[11] Pyle was executive officer for the State Securities Commission from 1931 to 1933.
While pursuing her political career, Pyle also became active in the life insurance business, and worked as an agent for several companies, including New York Life Insurance Company[21] and Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance.[22] In addition, she was elected president of the Huron Life Underwriters Association,[23] and was active in the National Association of Life Underwriters.[22]
U.S. Senator
Pyle on November 28, 1938, during her brief Senate term
On November 8, 1938, she was elected as a Republican to the United States Senate, winning over 58% of the vote and receiving about 8,500 more votes than the second highest statewide election winner. Pyle received the highest percentage of the vote for non-incumbent Republican nominees and second highest percentage of the vote for all Republican nominees for the U.S. Senate in the 1938 elections. Pyle was elected to fill the vacancy caused by the death of Peter Norbeck.[1] Norbeck died in December 1936, which allowed the governor of South Dakota to appoint a replacement, and he appointed Democrat Herbert E. Hitchcock.[1] Hitchcock lost the primary for the Democratic nomination for a full term, and the general election was won by Republican Chan Gurney.[1] Because he lost the Democratic nomination, a quirk in South Dakota law required Hitchcock to step down following the November 1938 election, which would have created a vacancy before Gurney's term began in January 1939.[1] To fill the two month vacancy, South Dakota Republicans successfully pushed for a special election because of rumors that President Franklin D. Roosevelt would call a special session of Congress to be held before January.[1] State law also prevented Gurney from appearing on the ballot twice, so he was unable to run in the special election.[1]
As a result of these circumstances and the quirks in the law, the Republican Party prevailed upon Pyle, despite her pledge not seek any further partisan political office, to run in the special election, in part because of her popularity in the state, and in part because she had the name recognition that they would not have to devote many resources to the special election campaign.[1] She campaigned against the New Deal, arguing the program had not gone far enough to help the people of South Dakota.[2] On the same day that Gurney won election to a full term, Pyle easily defeated Democrat J. T. McCullen Sr. for the short one, running about 6 percentage points ahead of the winning percentage of the next highest statewide office election winner.[1] Pyle was paid for her Senate service and allowed to hire staff, but the Congress was not in session and she was never sworn in.[24]
After the election, Pyle traveled to Washington, D.C. at her own expense, accompanied by her mother and one aide.[2] No special session was called, so Pyle did not have the opportunity to perform any official Senate duties before her term ended.[1] She shared a Senate office with Thomas M. Storke, an appointed interim senator from California, and spent her time in Washington lobbying federal agencies including the Works Progress Administration and Bureau of Indian Affairs for approval of projects in South Dakota.[1][25]
Later career
In January 1939, Pyle returned to her insurance business, and remained closely involved in public service work.[2] In 1940, she became the first woman to deliver a presidential nominating speech at a national convention, speaking on behalf of candidate Harland J. Bushfield.[1]
In addition to resuming her career in the life insurance business, Pyle was the guardian for two orphaned boys and managed her family's 640-acre farm near Huron.[26] She was a member of the South Dakota Board of Charities and Corrections from 1943 to 1957.[1]
Death and burial
In 1988, Pyle became the oldest living current or former U.S. senator.[27] She died in Huron on March 14, 1989, aged 98.[1] Her ashes are interred at Riverside Cemetery in Huron.[28]
Legacy
The Pyle House, the family home that Gladys Pyle lived in from 1894 until 1985 is on the National Register of Historic Places and has been converted into a museum.[3] Pyle recorded her own recollections of the home before her death, in preparation for its conversion.[3] It is largely unchanged from when it was built and has many of the original furnishings and interior decorations.[29]
