Nagler was born in Marysville, California and raised in nearby Arboga[1] He attended Marysville High School (class of 1949), where he was an all-league selection in football his junior and senior years.[1][2] He attended the University of Santa Clara (class of 1953), majoring in history,[1] and was a captain of the varsity football team in his senior year.[3]
NFL career
Nagler was drafted in the 14th round of the 1953 NFL draft by the Cleveland Browns.[4] Prior to the season starting, the Browns completed a fifteen-player trade—which set the NFL record for the largest trade ever executed—that sent Nagler and nine other players to the Baltimore Colts.[5] The Colts then waived him prior to the start of the 1953 NFL season. He was claimed off waivers by the Chicago Cardinals.[6] In his rookie season, Nagler set the Cardinals team record for receptions in a rookie season, with 43.[7]
Nagler missed the 1954 NFL season due to service in the United States Army. While posted at Fort Sill, Oklahoma, lieutenant Nagler helped coach the base football team to a perfect 12-0 record and the All-Service Championship,[8] winning the 1954 Poinsettia Bowl.[9][10]
He returned to the Cardinals in 1955, spending the next four seasons with the club. Nagler earned a Pro Bowl selection in 1958.[11]
Following his Pro Bowl year, Nagler was traded to the Pittsburgh Steelers and spent one season with the team.[12] He was moved to the Cleveland Browns as part of a four-player New Year's Eve trade that included Steelers quarterback Len Dawson.[13] Nagler finished his playing career after the 1961 NFL season, after two seasons with the Browns.[12]
Nagler was involved with the early efforts to organize a players' union, and was a key figure in the creation of the first players' pension. Nagler and Cleveland Browns end Billy Howton presented NFL CommissionerBert Bell with a draft antitrust lawsuit, threatening to file if the NFL did not immediately establish a pension for its players.[14] The gambit worked, and the pension was formally established three years later.[14]
Personal life and death
Following retirement from the NFL, Nagler worked in various aspects of the farming and agriculture industry, splitting time between southern California and the Hillsboro, Oregon area.[1]
Nagler was married three times, to Diana Swift (divorced 1975), Barbara Bertolini (1976-1995), and Jan Anacker (1998-2020).[1] He and Diana had three children together.[2]
He was inducted into the Santa Clara Hall of Fame in 1987 and the Marysville High School Hall of Fame in 2019.[3][1]