In 2005, the theater was used for filming the Prairie Home Companion movie directed by Robert Altman.[2] While a certain level of realism is added by using the normal venue for the show, the regular equipment was eschewed in favor of sets designed for the movie. Because the theater is a small building, other theaters in the region were also scouted prior to filming, just in case the Fitzgerald was not big enough, but eventually it was determined to be adequate for the film's needs.[7]
In March 2019 Twin Cities venue operator, First Avenue, purchased The Fitzgerald Theater from MPR.[8]