The song was listed at number 266 on Pitchfork Media's "Top 500 Tracks of the 2000s".[2]
The music video displays a variety of couples as well as single people wearing headphones while sitting on a couch. The video received a Special Recognition in the 2006 GLAAD Media Awards due to its inclusion of gay and lesbian couples.[3]
In 2013, Stereogum ranked the song number five on their list of the 10 greatest Bright Eyes songs,[5] and in 2020, Paste ranked the song number seven on their list of the 15 greatest Bright Eyes songs.[6]
The song appeared in the 2017 Netflix mini series Atypical (season 2, episode 6), the Showtime series Ray Donovan (season 6, episode 12), and in the CW series Roswell, New Mexico (season 1, episode 6 and season 2, episode 5).[citation needed]