Finanzamt Köln Altstadt v Schumacker

Finanzamt Köln Altstadt v Schumacker
CourtEuropean Court of Justice
Citation(1995) C-279/93
Keywords
Free movement of workers

Finanzamt Köln Altstadt v Schumacker (1995) C-279/93 is an EU law case, concerning the free movement of workers in the European Union.

Facts

Roland Schumacker argued that he should get extra tax benefits in Germany. He was Belgian, lived in Belgium and worked in Germany. He paid German income tax, but was denied benefits that resident taxpayers received. Germany argued that it was hard to determine the income received by non-residents in their state of residence to assess deductions.

Judgment

The Court of Justice held that a non-resident taxpayer who receives almost all income in a state of employment is objectively comparable to someone who does the same work there. It followed that Schumacker should be entitled to the tax benefits.

27 It is true that the rules at issue in the main proceedings apply irrespective of the nationality of the taxpayer concerned.

28 However, national rules of that kind, under which a distinction is drawn on the basis of residence in that non-residents are denied certain benefits which are, conversely, granted to persons residing within national territory, are liable to operate mainly to the detriment of nationals of other Member States. Non-residents are in the majority of cases foreigners.

29 In those circumstances, tax benefits granted only to residents of a Member State may constitute indirect discrimination by reason of nationality.

[...]

38 In the case of a non-resident who receives the major part of his income and almost all his family income in a Member State other than that of his residence, discrimination arises from the fact that his personal and family circumstances are taken into account neither in the State of residence nor in the State of employment.

39 The further question arises whether there is any justification for such discrimination.

[...]

41 ... In a situation such as that in the main proceedings, the State of residence cannot take account of the taxpayer' s personal and family circumstances because the tax payable there is insufficient to enable it to do so. Where that is the case, the Community principle of equal treatment requires that, in the State of employment, the personal and family circumstances of a foreign non-resident be taken into account in the same way as those of resident nationals and that the same tax benefits should be granted to him.

42 The distinction at issue in the main proceedings is thus in no way justified by the need to ensure the cohesion of the applicable tax system.

43 At the hearing, the Finanzamt argued that administrative difficulties prevent the State of employment from ascertaining the income which non-residents working in its territory receive in their State of residence.

44 That argument likewise cannot be upheld.

45 Council Directive 77/799/EEC of 19 December 1977 concerning mutual assistance by the competent authorities of the Member States in the field of direct taxation (OJ 1977 L 336, p. 15) provides for ways of obtaining information comparable to those existing between tax authorities at national level. There is thus no administrative obstacle to account being taken in the State of employment of a non-resident' s personal and family circumstances.

See also

Notes

References

Read other articles:

Britten-Norman Defender

Britten -Norman Defender adalah pesawat angkut utilitas multi-peran, diproduksi oleh Britten-Norman dari Inggris. Ini adalah versi militer dari Britten-Norman Islander, yang dikembangkan untuk peran seperti transportasi utilitas, evakuasi korban, kontra-pemberontakan dan serangan ringan, kendali udara depan, patroli dan pengintaian. Istilah 'Britten-Norman Defender' berkaitan dengan semua varian militer dari lini produk BN-2 termasuk BN-2 Piston Defender, BN-2T Turbine Defender (kadang-kadang...

 

 

Airbus A340

Airbus A340Airbus A340-300 milik Philippine AirlinesA300 · A310 · A320 · A330 · A340 · A350 · A380 · A400MTipePesawat terbang komersialTerbang perdana25 Oktober 1991DiperkenalkanMaret 1993 (pengiriman mulai pada Januari 1993)Statustidak diproduksi, dalam pelayananPengguna utamaLufthansaPengguna lainIberia Airlines Virgin Atlantic Airways South African Airways Awostastia AirlinesTahun produksi1991-2011Jumlah produksi375 unitHarga satuanA340-200: $ 87 juta dolar (1989)A340-300: $ 211,8 ...

 

 

Danau Gippsland

Pencitraan Landsat 7 dari Danau Gippsland. Danau Entrance terlihat di bagian kanan atas gambar. Danau-danau Gippsland adalah jaringan danau, rawa dan laguna di Gippsland timur, Victoria, Australia seluas sekitar 600 km persegi, danau terbesarnya adalah Danau Wellington (bahasa Gunai: Murla[1]), Danau King dan Danau Victoria. Mereka dimasukkan oleh sungai Avon, Thomson, Latrobe, Mitchell, Nicholson dan Tambo. Danau terbentuk oleh dua proses utama. Yang pertama adalah delta sungai endap...

Calcite

Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento mineralogia non cita le fonti necessarie o quelle presenti sono insufficienti. Puoi migliorare questa voce aggiungendo citazioni da fonti attendibili secondo le linee guida sull'uso delle fonti. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. CalciteClassificazione Strunz5.AB.05 Formula chimicaCaCO3 Proprietà cristallograficheGruppo cristallinodimetrico Sistema cristallinotrigonale Classe di simmetriascalenoedrica ditrigonale Parametri di cellaa=4...

 

 

Tüp District

District in Issyk-Kul, KyrgyzstanTüp Kyrgyz: Түп районуDistrict Coat of armsCoordinates: 42°45′N 78°20′E / 42.750°N 78.333°E / 42.750; 78.333CountryKyrgyzstanRegionIssyk-KulArea • Total2,121 km2 (819 sq mi)Population (2021) • Total65,169 • Density31/km2 (80/sq mi)Time zoneUTC+6 Tüp (Kyrgyz: Түп району) is a district of Issyk-Kul Region in north-eastern Kyrgyzstan. The seat lies at ...

 

 

Madras Cafe

Madras CafePoster teatrikalSutradaraShoojit SircarProduserJohn Abraham[1]Viacom 18 Motion PicturesRonnie Lahiri[2][3][4]Ditulis olehSomnath DeyShubendu BhattacharyaJuhi Chaturvedi (dialog)PemeranJohn AbrahamNargis FakhriRashi KhannaSiddharth BasuPrakash BelawadiPenata musikShantanu MoitraSinematograferKamaljeet NegiPenyuntingChandrashekhar PrajapatiPerusahaanproduksiJA EntertainmentRising Sun FilmsDistributorViacom 18 Motion PicturesTanggal rilis 23 Agust...

Kortrijk

Kortrijk (Belanda)MunicipalityTugu Broel di Kortrijk BenderaLambang kebesaranLocation of Kortrijk (Belanda) Negara BelgiaMasyarakatMasyarakat FlandriaDaerahDaerah FlandriaProvinsiFlandria BaratArrondissementKortrijkPemerintahan • Wali KotaRudolf Scherpereel (N-VA) • Partai penguasaOpen VLD, N-VA, SP.aLuas • Total80,69 km2 (3,115 sq mi)Populasi (2022-01-01)[1] • Total77.741 • Kepadatan9,6/km2 (25/...

 

 

John Kirby (laksamana)

John Kirby Wakil Menteri Pertahanan untuk Urusan MasyarakatPetahanaMulai menjabat 20 Januari 2021PresidenJoe Biden PendahuluJonathan Rath HoffmanPenggantiPetahanaWakil Menteri Urusan MasyarakatMasa jabatan11 Desember 2015 – 20 Januari 2017PresidenBarack ObamaWakilSusan Stevenson PendahuluDouglas FrantzPenggantiMichelle GiudaJurubicara Kementerian Luar Negeri Amerika SerikatMasa jabatan13 Mei 2015 – 20 Januari 2017PresidenBarack ObamaWakilMark Toner PendahuluJen Psaki...

 

 

Hong Sang-soo

Ini adalah nama Korea; marganya adalah Hong. Hong Sang-sooHong Sang-soo on the set of Night and Day, 5 September 2007Lahir25 Oktober 1961 (umur 62)Seoul, South KoreaPekerjaanFilm directorNama KoreaHangul홍상수 Hanja洪尚秀 Alih AksaraHong Sang-suMcCune–ReischauerHong Sangsu Hong Sang-soo (lahir 25 Oktober 1961) adalah sutradara dan penulis skenario film berkebangsaan Korea Selatan. Namanya mulai dikenal oleh publik Korea Selatan sejak tahun 1996 ketika mengarahkan film The Day a P...

Sacerdote (ebraismo)

«Ti sia gradito, HaShem nostro Dio e Dio dei nostri padri, piegare il nostro istinto al Tuo servizio per tutti i giorni della nostra vita, sempre. Amen, così Ti sia gradito» (Avodah, preghiera ebraica rivolta a Dio) I sacerdoti del TabernacoloBibbia Foster, 1897 Nella religione ebraica il sacerdote o cohen, pl. cohanim (ebraico כּהן kohèn, pl. כּוהנים kohanîm)[1] è una figura religiosa preposta all'esercizio del culto, detto avodah, e alla mediazione dei rapporti con...

 

 

حوالي

لا يزال النص الموجود في هذه الصفحة في مرحلة الترجمة من الإنجليزية إلى العربية. إذا كنت تعرف اللغة الإنجليزية، لا تتردد في الترجمة من النص الأصلي باللغة الإنجليزية. (أبريل 2019)Learn how and when to remove this message   لمعانٍ أخرى، طالع حوالي (توضيح). قرابةمعلومات عامةجانب من جوانب تاريخ �...

 

 

Ordnance Survey National Grid

System of geographic grid references used in Great Britain For the electricity network, see National Grid (Great Britain). This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Ordnance Survey National Grid – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (November 2008) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Ge...

Ткачов Володимир Васильович

У Вікіпедії є статті про інших людей із прізвищем Ткачов. Володимир Васильович Ткачов Народження 14 жовтня 1946(1946-10-14) (77 років)Лабінськ Краснодарський крайКраїна  УкраїнаРід військ ЗС УкраїниЗвання  Генерал-полковникКомандування Повітряні Сили Збройних Сил України�...

 

 

Second Taiwan Strait Crisis

1958 period of conflict and heightened tension between mainland China and Taiwan This article includes a list of general references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding inline citations. Please help to improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (August 2011) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Second Taiwan Strait CrisisPart of the Chinese Civil War and the Cold WarTaiwan StraitDate23 August – 2 December 1958 (3 months, 1 week and 2 day...

 

 

Andrey Karlov

Andrey KarlovAndrey Karlov, Duta Besar Rusia untuk Turki, dan Korea Utara, 2016Lahir4 Februari 1954Meninggal19 Desember 2016 (Umur 62) Andrey Karlov (4 Februari 1954 – 19 Desember 2016) adalah duta besar Rusia untuk Turki yang ditembak mati di Ankara oleh polisi Turki yang sedang tidak bertugas saat memberi pidato pada pembukaan galeri seni di Ankara.[1] Rujukan ^ Telegraph: Russian ambassador to Turkey Andrey Karlov shot dead by police officer in Ankara who shouted 'Aleppo, revenge'

Turf Moor

Turf MoorThe Turf Informasi stadionPemilikLongside HoldingsOperatorBurnley F.C.LokasiLokasiHarry Potts Way,BurnleyLancashire BB10 4BX InggrisKoordinat53°47′21″N 2°13′49″W / 53.78917°N 2.23028°W / 53.78917; -2.23028Koordinat: 53°47′21″N 2°13′49″W / 53.78917°N 2.23028°W / 53.78917; -2.23028KonstruksiMulai pembangunan1833 (sebagai lapangan kriket)[1]Dibuka17 February 1883[1]Biaya pembuatan£5.3 jutaData ...

 

 

Hallucination (song)

2022 single by Regard and Years & Years HallucinationSingle by Regard and Years & Yearsfrom the album Night Call LanguageEnglishReleased18 February 2022 (2022-02-18)Genre Disco-pop synth-pop Length2:54LabelMinistry of SoundSongwriter(s) Regard Olly Alexander Jean-Jacques Goldman Joel Little Nadia Mladjao Stéfane Goldman Producer(s)RegardRegard singles chronology Signals (2021) Hallucination (2022) No Love For You (2022) Olly Alexander singles chronology Sweet ...

 

 

Oregon Graduate Institute

Former higher education institution in Beaverton, Oregon Oregon Graduate InstituteFormer namesOregon Graduate CenterTypePrivateEstablished1963 - 2001EndowmentUS $14.8MPresidentEdward W. ThompsonProvostPaul Clayton[1]Academic staff153 (1995)Students1100 (1995)Undergraduates0Postgraduates1100LocationBeaverton-Hillsboro, Oregon, U.S.45°31′58″N 122°52′46″W / 45.5327°N 122.8794°W / 45.5327; -122.8794CampusCollege town, 75 acres (30 ha)Websitewww.ohs...

La strada buia (film 1950)

La strada buiaJanis Paige e Massimo Serato in una scena del filmTitolo originaleFugitive Lady Lingua originaleinglese Paese di produzioneItalia, Regno Unito Anno1950 Durata86 min Dati tecniciB/Nrapporto: 1,37 : 1 Generedrammatico, giallo RegiaMarino Girolami e (per la vers. anglofona) Sidney Salkow SoggettoPhilip Jordan (dal romanzo Dark Road) SceneggiaturaJohn O'Dea Casa di produzioneScalera Film, Venus Film, Mitchell John Frankovich Distribuzione in italianoScalera Film Fotogra...

 

 

Luciana Turina

Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento attori è priva o carente di note e riferimenti bibliografici puntuali. Sebbene vi siano una bibliografia e/o dei collegamenti esterni, manca la contestualizzazione delle fonti con note a piè di pagina o altri riferimenti precisi che indichino puntualmente la provenienza delle informazioni. Puoi migliorare questa voce citando le fonti più precisamente. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Luciana TurinaLuciana Turina in Ciao marziano (...