Sears announced in 2013 that it closed the Fashion Place store and the building was demolished and replaced with a new Dillard's in 2015.[6] The old building would later be demolished in 2016. The closure of the Macy's store, one of the smallest in the chain, was announced in January 2014.[7] By year's end, the former Macy's became The Container Store, the first in Utah.[8] Macy's returned to the Fashion Place Mall in early March 2017, located in the old Dillard's space.
On November 8, 1974, serial killer Ted Bundy attempted and failed to kidnap Carol Da Ronch from the mall. This eventually led to his first conviction, putting him behind bars for the first time.
On January 13, 2019, at about 1:30pm, a gang-related shooting injured two members,[10] one in critical condition. Five men were charged in connection with the shooting,[11] with several wanted suspects still at large. Two Florencia 13 members, males aged 19 and 20, were charged in the attack.[12] The entire mall was evacuated by police shortly after the shooting, and reopened Monday to the public.[13]