McEvoy joined the Magherafelt senior team in 2021, and played in his first county final in 2023. McEvoy lined out at centre back for the final against Glen. McEvoy scored a point in the first half, but Glen ran out winners after a strong second half.[5]
Inter-county
Minor and under-20
On 2 July 2021, McEvoy was at centre back for Derry's delayed 2020 Ulster minor final win over Monaghan.[6] On 18 July 2021, McEvoy scored a point in the All-Ireland final as Derry defeated Kerry to win the 2020 All-Ireland Minor Football Championship.[7] McEvoy was named at centre back on the Minor Football Team of the Year.[8]
McEvoy was on the Derry under-20 panel in 2023, but didn't feature due to a rule that bars players from playing with their U20 and senior teams within seven days of each other.[9] Derry contested the Ulster final against Down on 26 April, but McEvoy didn't play as Derry lost the final by 2–11 to 0–9.[10]
Senior
McEvoy joined the Derry senior panel ahead of the 2022 season.[11] He didn't feature in the league or championship, as Derry won their first Ulster championship in 24 years.[12]
McEvoy made his National League debut on 30 January 2023, starting at full back in a twelve-point win over Limerick.[13] He kept his place for the rest of the league as Derry were promoted to Division 1 with a game to spare.[14] McEvoy didn't start the Division 2 final against Dublin, coming on as a late sub in the 4–6 to 0–11 defeat.[15] McEvoy made his championship debut on 28 April, starting the game and scoring a point in a win over Fermanagh.[16] Derry reached the Ulster final for the second consecutive year after a semi-final win over Monaghan.[17] On 14 May, McEvoy started the final, playing the full game as Derry beat Armagh after a penalty shoot-out.[18] On 16 July, McEvoy played in Derry's All-Ireland semi-final loss to defending champions Kerry.[19] At the end of the season, McEvoy received his first All-Star nomination, and was also nominated for the Young Footballer of the Year award.[20]
In the 2024 league, Derry topped the table, qualifying for the final against Dublin.[21] McEvoy started the final at centre back, scoring 2–2 and was man of the match as Derry won the league for the first time since 2008 after a penalty shoot-out win.[22]