The Elmira Juniors played at the Junior "C" level during the 1950s and 1960s, winning the Clarence Schmalz Cup in 1962.
The Elmira Sugar Kings' 1st season was in 1971–72, but in 1973, the Sugar Kings entered the Southwestern Junior "B" Hockey League. In that first Junior "B" season, the Sugar Kings won the league championship. In 1974, the league became the Waterloo-Wellington Junior "B" Hockey League, which changed its name to the Midwestern "B" in 1977.
Through much of their first 20 years, the Kings were inconsistent—some years finishing with more than 30 wins, some years fewer than 10. But throughout the late 1990s and early 2000s, the Sugar Kings were one of the most dominant teams in Canadian junior hockey. In 1997, 1998, 2001, 2002, 2008 and 2011 the Kings reigned as Mid-Western "B" champions, winning the Sutherland Cup as Ontario Hockey Association Junior B champions in 1997, 2001, 2011, 2017.
Season-by-season record
Season
GP
W
L
T
OTL
GF
GA
P
Results
Playoffs
1971-72
39
21
12
6
-
185
166
48
3rd WOJHL
1972-73
42
19
20
3
-
198
186
41
5th WOJHL
1973-74
40
20
15
6
-
192
166
46
4th SWJBHL
Won League
1974-75
40
19
15
6
-
189
157
44
4th WWJHL
1975-76
41
12
20
9
-
181
203
33
6th WWJHL
Lost quarter-final
1976-77
39
13
21
5
-
194
213
31
5th WWJHL
DNQ
1977-78
40
13
20
7
-
162
193
33
4th MWJBHL
Lost semi-final
1978-79
42
30
7
5
-
234
149
65
2nd MWJBHL
Lost final
1979-80
42
16
23
3
-
204
262
35
4th MWJBHL
Lost semi-final
1980-81
42
6
35
1
-
142
286
13
8th MWJBHL
DNQ
1981-82
42
1
40
1
-
118
363
3
8th MWJBHL
DNQ
1982-83
42
7
34
1
-
146
295
15
7th MWJBHL
DNQ
1983-84
42
17
24
1
-
170
198
35
6th MWJBHL
Lost semi-final
1984-85
42
17
24
1
-
179
220
35
6th MWJBHL
Lost quarter-final
1985-86
40
22
17
1
-
206
178
45
3rd MWJBHL
Lost semi-final
1986-87
42
31
11
0
-
292
140
62
3rd MWJBHL
Lost final
1987-88
48
35
11
2
-
286
175
72
2nd MWJBHL
Lost final
1988-89
48
19
24
5
-
241
251
43
6th MWJBHL
Lost semi-final
1989-90
48
26
21
1
-
262
227
53
4th MWJBHL
Lost quarter-final
1990-91
48
8
39
1
-
195
367
17
8th MWJBHL
Lost quarter-final
1991-92
48
6
39
3
-
145
273
15
9th MWJBHL
DNQ
1992-93
48
14
33
1
-
192
283
29
7th MWJBHL
Lost quarter-final
1993-94
48
27
17
4
-
222
174
58
5th MWJBHL
Lost quarter-final
1994-95
48
29
14
5
-
229
169
63
2nd MWJBHL
Lost final
1995-96
48
20
26
2
-
198
214
42
7th MWJBHL
Lost semi-final
1996-97
48
31
11
6
-
257
166
68
2nd MWJBHL
Won League, won SC
1997-98
48
33
12
3
-
259
137
69
2nd MWJBHL
Won League
1998-99
48
29
14
5
-
225
187
63
3rd MWJBHL
Lost semi-final
1999-00
48
33
12
3
-
203
116
69
3rd MWJBHL
Lost semi-final
2000-01
48
28
15
5
-
217
158
61
3rd MWJBHL
Won League, won SC
2001-02
48
38
5
5
-
254
128
81
1st MWJBHL
Won League
2002-03
48
17
28
3
0
178
199
37
9th MWJBHL
DNQ
2003-04
47
20
19
4
4
191
175
48
6th MWJBHL
2004-05
48
27
13
3
5
199
155
62
6th MWJBHL
2005-06
48
27
19
2
-
201
150
56
3rd MWJBHL
Lost quarter-final
2006-07
48
36
8
4
0
262
165
76
2nd MWJBHL
Lost final
2007-08
48
30
7
8
3
196
124
71
1st GOJHL-MW
Lost final
2008-09
52
23
24
-
5
207
215
51
7th GOJHL-MW
Lost Conf. QF
2009-10
51
20
26
-
5
163
188
45
6th GOJHL-MW
Lost Conf. SF
2010-11
51
34
15
-
2
219
153
70
2nd GOJHL-MW
Won League, won SC
2011-12
51
40
9
-
2
240
134
82
3rd GOJHL-MW
2012-13
51
25
21
-
5
180
183
55
7th GOJHL-MW
Lost Conf. QF
2013-14
49
34
10
-
5
187
117
73
2nd GOJHL-MW
Lost Conf. SF
2014-15
49
38
7
-
4
215
127
80
1st GOJHL-MW
Won Conf. Quarters, 4-0 (Bombers) Won Conf. Semis, 4-0 (Siskins) Won Conf. Finals, 4-1 (Cullitons) Lost Sutherland Semifinals, 3-4 (Vipers)
Won Conf. Quarters, 4-0 (Hurricanes) Won Conf. Semifinals, 4-2 (Dutchmen) Lost Conf. Finals, 2-4 (Cyclones) advance as Wild Card Won Sutherland Cup Semis 4-2 (Corvairs) Won Sutherland Cup Finals 4-1 (Nationals)
2017-18
50
29
21
0
0
181
155
58
3rd of 8-MW 12th of 26-GOJHL
Won Conf. Quarters, 4-0 (Bombers) Won Conf. Semifinal 4-2 (Warriors) Lost Conf. Finals 0-4 (Cyclones) advance as Wild Card Lost Sutherland Cup Semis 0-4 (Corvairs)