Policy worked for the law firm Heller Ehrman in San Francisco and then the Cleveland-based Thompson Hine LLP, where he worked on sports facility construction.[6]
Arena Football League
Policy began working for the Arena Football League in 2001, eventually briefly becoming Commissioner of the league when he took over on an interim basis for Commissioner C. David Baker, who stepped down two days before the 2008 ArenaBowl.[7][8] Because the league subsequently shut down for the 2009 season, with the initial corporate organization filing for bankruptcy, the only actual AFL game contested during Policy's tenure as commissioner was the 2008 ArenaBowl (ArenaBowl XXII).[9]
National Football League
Beginning in 2009 Policy worked as a consultant for the National Football League, but left prior to the 2011 NFL lockout.[6]
Green Bay Packers
Team executive
In 2012 the Green Bay Packers hired Policy to serve as vice president and general counsel.[10] He was promoted to chief operating officer and general counsel in January 2018. The Packers said in a statement that Policy would “take on a greater role in overseeing the business operations of the organization…"[11][12] Since being named COO, Policy has overseen the development of the Packers' Titletown District.[13][14][15]
In February 2020, amid rumors that Green Bay was successful in their bid to host the 2022 NFL draft, Policy said that the NFL had not awarded the rights to host the draft to Green Bay or any other city, but that the Packers would, "aggressively pursue the opportunity."[16][17] Green Bay was eventually awarded the right to host the 2025 NFL draft, which Policy stated would be the largest event Green Bay ever hosted.[18]
Team president
In June 2024, the Packers announced Policy would replace Mark Murphy as the team's president and chief executive officer in July 2025.[19] The team's board of directors elected Policy unanimously after a search committee winnowed a list of more than 90 candidates.[20]