Hannah was born in County Down in Ireland but relocated to Dunbartonshire in Scotland with his family during his childhood. After emerging as a teenager with Renton, he transferred to Sunderland in early 1890 alongside teammates Johnny Campbell and John Harvey.[2] They became members of the all-Scottish 'team of all the talents' which won consecutive Football League championships in 1891–92 and 1892–93.[3]
Liverpool bought Hannah in November 1894 to boost their attacking options. He scored six goals in 17 games during a season in which the Reds were relegated to the Second Division, and three in 11 as they were promoted back to the top tier 1895–96. By the time he left Liverpool in 1897 he had played 33 league and FA Cup games, scoring 12 goals.[4] His teammates at Anfield included former Renton defender Andrew Hannah, and Jimmy Hannah played alongside him in the forward line at Sunderland – neither was a direct relation, although Andrew's parents were also from County Down[5] and the men were possibly cousins to a degree.
After a short spell back in Scotland with Dundee,[6][7][8] he returned to England with Second Division Woolwich Arsenal, making his debut in the 3–2 loss at Walsall on 6 November 1897. He stayed in London for two seasons, speaking highly of the level of play in the south of England (which at that time was considered by some in the north as inferior to their standards)[9] before retiring from football at the end of the 1899 season, having made 50 appearances and scoring 17 goals.[10] He died in 1936.[11]
Despite his success at club level with Sunderland, Hannah was never capped as an international – being Irish-born he was ineligible for Scotland under rules of the time, and Ireland were possibly unaware that he could play for them, assuming that he was simply one of the many 'Anglo-Scots' who were overlooked by the Scottish Football Association for selection until 1896.[a]
^He is credited with one representative appearance for the Football Alliance XI in 1891 by some sources,[12] but the player involved was Jimmy Hannah who at the time was playing for Alliance members Sunderland Albion.
^John Litster (October 2012). "A Record of pre-war Scottish League Players". Scottish Football Historian magazine. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)