He played quarterback and halfback for the University of Pennsylvania football team in 1908 and 1909.[1] He also performed punting duties for Penn and first gained acclaim as "the great punter of 1908."[2]The New York Times described him as "the star back-field" player for the 1909 Penn Quakers football team.[3] In 1910, Hutchinson was declared ineligible to play football by Penn's faculty athletic committee because of "conditions in his studies."[4] The loss of Hutchinson was described as "a severe blow to Pennsylvania's football prospects."[4]
Coach
In 1912, he served as an assistant football coach under Andy Smith at the University of Pennsylvania.[5] In April 1913, he was hired as the head football coach at Wesleyan University.[5] In his single season as Wesleyan's head football coach, Hutchinson compiled a 5–3–1 record.[6] In December 1913, Wesleyan announced that Hutchinson would not be re-engaged as the football coach for the 1914 season. The New York Times reported that the team had made a good showing in the early part of the season but had slumped in the final two games against Williams College and Trinity College.[7] Hutchinson later became a tennis player. In March 1920, he was defeated in a doubles match in the second round of the annual tournament for the court tennis championship of the United States.[8]