The Colonials' franchise was purchased from the Niagara Falls PowerHawks organization[4] and Kevin Cunningham was named as the first head coach of the Colonials.[5] Billy McCreary, son of former NHL player Bill McCreary Jr., was named the FPHL team's head coach and general manager.[6] Former NHL player Colton Orr was named as co-owner and managing partner of both teams.[7] The Colonials finished in second the Northeast Division in their inaugural season, but the playoffs were curtailed by the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in March 2020.[8]
On May 11, 2020, the organization announced they had also bought a franchise in the Tier II juniorNorth American Hockey League (NAHL) from the Wilkes-Barre/Scranton Knights and would be named the Danbury Jr. Hat Tricks after the professional team. Billy McCreary, who had won Coach of the Year in the FPHL in his first season, stepped down from his coaching position with the professional team and became head coach of the NAHL team.[9] Subsequently, the Colonials would also be rebranded before the 2020–21 season to align with the rest of the organization.[10] Due to the limited capacity during the pandemic and interstate travel restrictions, the NA3HL team was one of several East Division teams to temporarily relocate to Massachusetts midseason, with the team playing out of Springfield, Massachusetts, as the Springfield Jr. Hat Tricks, before returning to Danbury in March 2021.[11][12]
Following the 2020–21 season, Doug Friedman was hired as the head coach of the Tier III Hat Tricks,[13] but left before coaching a game to join his alma mater, Boston University, as their director of hockey operations. The Jr. Hat Tricks then hired Tyler Noseworthy as head coach of the NA3HL team.[14]
Following the 2021-22 season, McCreary would return to be the Head Coach of the Danbury Hat Tricks while becoming President of Hockey Operations overseeing all three teams in the organization. [15] Longtime assistant coach Matt Voity became the Head Coach and General Manager of the NAHL team,[16] while Noseworthy remained with the NA3HL team, both would stay on as assistant coaches for the FPHL team.