In astronomy, the lithium problem or lithium discrepancy refers to the discrepancy between the primordial abundance of lithium as inferred from observations of metal-poor (Population II) halo stars in our galaxy and the amount that should theoretically exist due to Big Bang nucleosynthesis+WMAP cosmic baryon density predictions of the CMB. Namely, the most widely accepted models of the Big Bang suggest that three times as much primordial lithium, in particular lithium-7, should exist. This contrasts with the observed abundance of isotopes of hydrogen (1H and 2H) and helium (3He and 4He) that are consistent with predictions.[1] The discrepancy is highlighted in a so-called "Schramm plot", named in honor of astrophysicist David Schramm, which depicts these primordial abundances as a function of cosmic baryon content from standard BBN predictions.
Origin of lithium
Minutes after the Big Bang, the universe was made almost entirely of hydrogen and helium, with trace amounts of lithium and beryllium, and negligibly small abundances of all heavier elements.[3]
Lithium synthesis in the Big Bang
Big Bang nucleosynthesis produced both lithium-7 and beryllium-7, and indeed the latter dominates the primordial synthesis of mass 7 nuclides. On the other hand, the Big Bang produced lithium-6 at levels more than 1000 times smaller.
7 4Be later decayed via electron capture (half-life 53.22 days) into 7 3Li ,
so that the observable primordial lithium abundance essentially sums primordial 7 3Li and radiogenic lithium from the decay of 7 4Be .
The amount of lithium generated in the Big Bang can be calculated.[4]Hydrogen-1 is the most abundant nuclide, comprising roughly 92% of the atoms in the Universe, with helium-4 second at 8%. Other isotopes including 2H, 3H, 3He, 6Li, 7Li, and 7Be are much rarer; the estimated abundance of primordial lithium is 10−10 relative to hydrogen.[5] The calculated abundance and ratio of 1H and 4He is in agreement with data from observations of young stars.[3]
The P-P II branch is dominant at temperatures of 14 to 23 MK.
Observed abundance of lithium
Despite the low theoretical abundance of lithium, the actual observable amount is less than the calculated amount by a factor of 3–4.[6] This contrasts with the observed abundance of isotopes of hydrogen (1H and 2H) and helium (3He and 4He) that are consistent with predictions.[1]
Older stars seem to have less lithium than they should, and some younger stars have much more.[8] One proposed model is that lithium produced during a star's youth sinks beneath the star's atmosphere (where it is obscured from direct observation) due to effects the authors describe as "turbulent mixing" and "diffusion," which are suggested to increase or accumulate as the star ages.[9] Spectroscopic observations of stars in NGC 6397, a metal-poor globular cluster, are consistent with an inverse relation between lithium abundance and age, but a theoretical mechanism for diffusion has not been formalized.[10] Though it transmutes into two atoms of helium due to collision with a proton at temperatures above 2.4 million degrees Celsius (most stars easily attain this temperature in their interiors), lithium is more abundant than current computations would predict in later-generation stars.[11][12]
Lithium is also found in brown dwarf substellar objects and certain anomalous metal-poor stars. Because lithium is present in cooler, less massive brown dwarfs, but is destroyed in hotter red dwarf stars, its presence in the stars' spectra can be used in the "lithium test" to differentiate the two, as both are smaller than the Sun.[11][12][14]
Less lithium in Sun-like stars with planets
Sun-like stars without planets have 10 times the lithium as Sun-like stars with planets in a sample of 500 stars.[15][16] The Sun's surface layers have less than 1% the lithium of the original formation protosolar gas clouds despite the surface convective zone not being quite hot enough to burn lithium.[16] It is suspected that the gravitational pull of planets might enhance the churning up of the star's surface, driving the lithium to hotter cores where lithium burning occurs.[15][16] The absence of lithium could also be a way to find new planetary systems.[15] However, this claimed relationship has become a point of contention in the planetary astrophysics community, being frequently denied[17][18] but also supported.[19][20]
Higher than expected lithium in metal-poor stars
Certain metal-poor stars also contain an abnormally high concentration of lithium.[21] These stars tended to orbit massive objects—neutron stars or black holes—whose gravity evidently pulls heavier lithium to the surface of a hydrogen-helium star, causing more lithium to be observed.[11]
Proposed solutions
Possible solutions fall into three broad classes.
Astrophysical solutions
Considering the possibility that BBN predictions are sound, the measured value of the primordial lithium abundance should be in error and astrophysical solutions offer revision to it. For example, systematic errors, including ionization correction and inaccurate stellar temperatures determination could affect Li/H ratios in stars. Furthermore, more observations on lithium depletion remain important since present lithium levels might not reflect the initial abundance in the star. In summary, accurate measurements of the primordial lithium abundance is the current focus of progress, and it could be possible that the final answer does not lie in astrophysical solutions.[6]
Some astronomers suggest that the velocities of nucleons do not follow a Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. They test the framework of Tsallis non-extensive statistics. Their result suggest that 1.069 < q < 1.082 is a possible new solution to the cosmological lithium problem.[22]
Nuclear physics solutions
When one considers the possibility that the measured primordial lithium abundance is correct and based on the Standard Model of particle physics and the standard cosmology, the lithium problem implies errors in the BBN light element predictions. Although standard BBN rests on well-determined physics, the weak and strong interactions are complicated for BBN and therefore might be the weak point in standard BBN calculation.[6]
Firstly, incorrect or missing reactions could give rise to the lithium problem. For incorrect reactions, major thoughts lie within revision to cross section errors and standard thermonuclear rates according to recent studies.[23][24]
Second, starting from Fred Hoyle's discovery of a resonance in carbon-12, an important factor in the triple-alpha process, resonance reactions, some of which might have evaded experimental detection or whose effects have been underestimated, become possible solutions to the lithium problem.[25][26]
BBC Science Focus wrote in 2023 that "recent research seems to completely discount" such theories; the magazine held that mainstream lithium nucleosynthesis calculations are probably correct.[27]
Solutions beyond the Standard Model
Under the assumptions of all correct calculation, solutions beyond the existing Standard Model or standard cosmology might be needed.[6]
Dark matter decay and supersymmetry provide one possibility, in which decaying dark matter scenarios introduce a rich array of novel processes that can alter light elements during and after BBN, and find the well-motivated origin in supersymmetric cosmologies. With the fully operational Large Hadron Collider (LHC), much of minimal supersymmetry lies within reach, which would revolutionize particle physics and cosmology if discovered;[6] however, results from the ATLAS experiment in 2020 have excluded many supersymmetric models.[28][29]
Changing fundamental constants can be one possible solution, and it implies that first, atomic transitions in metals residing in high-redshift regions might behave differently from our own. Additionally, Standard Model couplings and particle masses might vary, and variation in nuclear physics parameters would be needed.[6]
Nonstandard cosmologies indicate variation of the baryon to photon ratio in different regions. One proposal is a result of large-scale inhomogeneities in cosmic density, different from homogeneity defined in the cosmological principle. However, this possibility requires a large amount of observations to test it.[30]
^ abLangmuir, C. H.; Broecker, W. S. (2012). How to Build a Habitable Planet: The Story of Earth from the Big Bang to Humankind. Princeton University Press. ISBN978-0691140063.
^Woo, M. (21 February 2017). "The Cosmic Explosions That Made the Universe". earth. BBC. Archived from the original on 21 February 2017. Retrieved 21 February 2017. A mysterious cosmic factory is producing lithium. Scientists are now getting closer at finding out where it comes from
^ abc
Israelian, G.; et al. (2009). "Enhanced lithium depletion in Sun-like stars with orbiting planets". Nature. 462 (7270): 189–191. arXiv:0911.4198. Bibcode:2009Natur.462..189I. doi:10.1038/nature08483. PMID19907489. S2CID388656. ... confirm the peculiar behaviour of Li in the effective temperature range 5600–5900 K ... We found that the immense majority of planet host stars have severely depleted lithium ... At higher and lower temperatures planet-host stars do not appear to show any peculiar behaviour in their Li abundance.
^Collaboration, Atlas (2021). "Search for squarks and gluinos in final states with jets and missing transverse momentum using 139 fb$^{-1}$ of $\sqrt{s}$ =13 TeV $pp$ collision data with the ATLAS detector". Jhep. 02: 143. arXiv:2010.14293. doi:10.1007/JHEP02(2021)143. S2CID256039464.
Air Albania IATA ICAO Kode panggil ZB ABN[1] AIR ALBANIA[1] Didirikan16 Mei 2018; 5 tahun lalu (2018-05-16)Mulai beroperasiApril 2019 (2019-04)PenghubungBandar Udara Internasional Tirana Nënë TerezaArmada2Tujuan8Kantor pusatTirana, AlbaniaTokoh utamaSinan Dilek (CEO)Situs webairalbania.com.al Air Albania adalah maskapai penerbangan nasional Albania.[2] Maskapai penerbangan ini mempertahankan hub dan kantor pusat perusahaannya di Bandar Udara Internasional T...
Kereta melewati Viaduk Martin Gil di Spanyol Infrastruktur fisik adalah sekumpulan fasilitas fisik yang dibangun oleh manusia sebagai sarana pendukung dalam memenuhi kebutuhan hidup sehari-hari. Fasilitas-fasilitas ini meliputi jalan, jembatan, gedung, sistem jaringan air dan listrik, sistem transportasi, dan lain-lain. Pentingnya infrastruktur fisik dapat dilihat dari fungsinya sebagai penghubung antarwilayah dan pembuka aksesibilitas. Dengan adanya infrastruktur fisik yang baik, aktivitas m...
Liga 3 Kepulauan Riau 2021Negara IndonesiaTanggal penyelenggaraan25 November–4 Desember 2021Tempat penyelenggaraan2 stadionJumlah peserta7 tim sepak bolaJuara bertahan757 Kepri Jaya FCJuara757 Kepri Jaya FC(gelar ke-2)Tempat keduaPS Shark TanjungpinangKualifikasi untukLiga 3 2021 Putaran Nasional← 2019 20222023 → Liga 3 Kepulauan Riau 2021 adalah edisi keempat dari Liga 3 Kepulauan Riau yang diselenggarakan oleh Asprov PSSI Kepulauan Riau.[1][2] Diikuti oleh 7 klub....
Koordinat: 7°44′46″S 112°13′05″E / 7.746224°S 112.2181374°E / -7.746224; 112.2181374 Hasil rekonstruksi bagian dasar Candi Surawana Candi Surawana (Surowono) adalah candi bercorak hinduistik yang terletak di Desa Canggu, Kecamatan Badas, Kabupaten Kediri, berjarak sekitar 25 km arah timur laut dari Kota Kediri. Candi ini disebut dalam kitab Negarakertagama dengan nama 'Wishnubhawanapura dan diperkirakan dibangun pada abad ke-14 untuk memuliakan Bhre Wengker...
American basketball player and coach (1924–2012) Not to be confused with Walter Kirk, an Australian World War I flying ace. A major contributor to this article appears to have a close connection with its subject. It may require cleanup to comply with Wikipedia's content policies, particularly neutral point of view. Please discuss further on the talk page. (July 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Walt KirkThe Illio, 1945Personal informationBorn(1924-09-03)September 3,...
Village in Powys, Wales Human settlement in WalesCwmdauddwrLocation within PowysCommunityRhayaderPrincipal areaPowysPreserved countyPowysCountryWalesSovereign stateUnited KingdomPoliceDyfed-PowysFireMid and West WalesAmbulanceWelsh List of places UK Wales Powys 52°17′54″N 3°31′00″W / 52.2984°N 3.5167°W / 52.2984; -3.5167 Cwmdauddwr (rarely referred to by its correct full name of Llansanffraid Cwmteuddwr[1]) is a village in Powys, Wale...
Lukisan karya Otto Runge. Philipp Otto Runge (23 Juli 1777 - 2 Desember 1810) adalah seorang pelukis dan penggambar aliran Romantis asal Jerman.[1] Pada masa awal kariernya Ia terlanjur mati muda, meski demikian orang-orang telah menganggap dirinya sebagai pelukis romantik terbaik di Jerman.[1] Runge lahir pada tanggal 9 dari 11 bersaudara di Wolgast, Western Pomerania, daerah Swedia, dalam sebuah keluarga pembuat kapal yang memiliki hubungan dengan bangsawan Prusia Sypniewski...
American actor (born 1951) Kurt RussellRussell at the 2016 San Diego Comic-ConBornKurt Vogel Russell (1951-03-17) March 17, 1951 (age 73)Springfield, Massachusetts, U.S.EducationThousand Oaks High SchoolOccupationActorYears active1962–presentSpouse(s) Season Hubley (m. 1979; div. 1983)Partner(s)Goldie Hawn (1983–present)Children2, including WyattParentBing Russell (father)RelativesMatt Franco (nephew) Kurt Vogel Russell (born M...
Turkish footballer and manager Rebii Erkal Rebii Erkal (10 February 1911 – 25 November 1985) was a Turkish footballer and manager. He was born in Istanbul. Erkal played for Galatasaray SK his whole career, making him memorable for many Gala supporters. He was also part of Turkey's squad at the 1936 Summer Olympics.[1] In 1951, after his active playing career ended, he became the manager of the Turkey national football team. Under Erkal's charge, the national squad managed to defeat ...
هايدن كرستنسين (بالإنجليزية: Hayden Christensen) هايدن كرستنسين في 2017 معلومات شخصية الميلاد 19 أبريل 1981 (العمر 43 سنة)فانكوفر، كولومبيا البريطانية، كندا مواطنة كندا الأولاد 1 عدد الأولاد 1 [1] والدان نيلسون العضويديفيد كرستنسین إخوة وأخوات توفي كريستنسن [لغات ...
1987–1990 political party in South Korea New Democratic Republican Party 신민주공화당新民主共和黨LeaderKim Jong-pilFounderKim Jong-pilFounded30 November 1987Dissolved14 February 1990Split fromKorean National PartySucceeded byDemocratic LiberalIdeologyConservatism (South Korean)Chungcheong regionalism[1]Political positionRight-wing[2]Colours GreenPolitics of South KoreaPolitical partiesElections This article is part of a series onConservatismi...
هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (مارس 2019) إدموند ميشيلز معلومات شخصية الميلاد 12 أكتوبر 1913 الجنسية بلجيكا الحياة العملية المهنة سباح، ولاعب كرة ماء الرياضة كرة الماء، والسباحة تعد...
Aliansi untuk Jerman (bahasa Jerman: Allianz für Deutschland) adalah sebuah koalisi perlawanan di Jerman Timur. Aliansi dibentuk pada 5 Februari 1990 di Berlin (Berlin Barat) untuk berdiri di pemilu Volkskammer Jerman Timur. Aliansi ini terdiri dari Persatuan Demokrat Kristen, Kebangkitan Demokrat, dan Persatuan Sosial Jerman. Partai Forum Jerman diundang untuk bergabung, tapi menolak.[1] Helmut Kohl di rapat umum pemilu Aliansi Jerman, 1990. Aliansi meraih suara terbanyak dalam ...
Questa voce sull'argomento schermidori ungheresi è solo un abbozzo. Contribuisci a migliorarla secondo le convenzioni di Wikipedia. Barnabás BerzsenyiNazionalità Ungheria Scherma SpecialitàSpada Palmarès Olimpiadi Ungheria ArgentoMelbourne 1956Spada sq. Mondiali ArgentoBruxelles 1953Spada in. BronzoRoma 1955Spada sq. ArgentoParigi 1957Spada sq. Statistiche aggiornate al 25 giugno 2009 Modifica dati su Wikidata · Manuale Barnabás Berzsenyi (Kemenesm...
Historic building in County Sligo, Ireland Classiebawn CastleLocation within IrelandGeneral informationLocationMullaghmore, County SligoCountryIrelandCoordinates54°27′18.55″N 8°28′9.59″W / 54.4551528°N 8.4693306°W / 54.4551528; -8.4693306Completed1874ClientLord PalmerstonDesign and constructionArchitect(s)J. Rawson Carroll Classiebawn Castle is a country house built for The 3rd Viscount Palmerston (1784–1865) on what was formerly a 4,000-hectare (10,000-a...
هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (مارس 2023) آيزو/آي إي سي 4909 (بالإنجليزية: ISO/IEC 4909) هو معيار دولي صادر من المنظمة الدولية للمعايير واللجنة الكهروتقنية الدولية، صدر المعيار في عام 2006 وتمت مراجعته في عام 2...
Den här artikeln handlar om den geopolitiska enheten Västbanken. För det israeliska distriktet Judeen och Samarien, se Judeen och Samarien (distrikt). Västbanken (הגדה המערביתالضفة الغربية) Judeen och Samarien Region Karta över Västbanken Administreras av Israel1 Palestinska myndigheten2 Gränsar till Södra distriktet, Jerusalem, Centrala distriktet, Haifa, Norra distriktet, Döda havet, Jordanien Huvudstad Ariel / Ramallah Area 5...
Vật lý hạt nhân Nucleus • Nucleons (Proton, Neutron) • Lực hạt nhân • Phản ứng hạt nhân Mô hình hạt nhânGiọt chất lỏng • Mô hình vỏ hạt nhân • Mô hình boson tương tácPhương pháp theo nguyên lý đầu Phân loại hạt nhânĐồng vị – bằng ZIsobars – bằng NĐồng neutron – bằng NIsodiapher – bằng N − Z Đồng phân – b�...