The Colts were on the losing end of two no–hitters in 1964. On July 3, 1964, Cocoa Met pitcher Tug McGraw threw a 7–inning no-hitter in his professional debut against the Cocoa Colts. McGraw defeated the Colts 4–0 in the victory.[3] On August 30, 1964, Gene Melton and Jerry Lyscio of the Melbourne Twins threw a combined 5–inning no–hitter in defeating the Colts by the score of 2–1.[4][5]
In their only season of play, the Cocoa Colts placed third in the Cocoa Rookie League final standings. With a record of 23–29, playing under manager Dave Philley, the Colts finished 11.0 games the first place Melbourne Twins (34–18) in the final regular season standings. The Colts finished behind the second place Cocoa Mets (28–22) and ahead of the fourth place Cocoa Tigers (17–33) in the final standings, as the league had no playoffs. The Cocoa Rookie League permanently folded after one season of play.[6][7][8][2]
The complex–based Colts and other Cocoa Rookie League teams charged fans no admission to games and individual attendance records were not kept. The Cocoa Rookie League games drew 1,683 total fans for the 1964 season schedule.[9]