UCF and UConn first met in 2013 after UCF left Conference USA and joined the American Athletic Conference. The first mention of the rivalry and associated trophy occurred after Connecticut's 37–29 victory over UCF in November 2014, which was Diaco's first FBS win as Connecticut head coach. The 2014 game also broke UCF's 11-game winning streak in conference play.
In a press statement Diaco said "We're excited about this game. I mean it. I'm excited to continue this game. With all admiration and respect. All admiration and respect for Central Florida and Coach O'Leary. They're spectacular. But we're excited about this North/South battle. You want to call it the Civil Conflict?"[5]
UCF head coach George O'Leary responded with "My experience is you’re more likely to have a rivalry against a team closer to where you live,” he said. “When you go 10 states away, I think it’s hard."[6] UCF's traditional rivalry has been with the University of South Florida located 90 miles away in Tampa, Florida, while UCF and UConn are 1,214 miles apart.
In response to this statement, Diaco released a statement of his own a week later that same week saying "They don't get to say whether they are our rival or not. We might not be their rival, but they don't get to say whether they are our rival—that is for us to decide."[7]
Trophy
In June 2015, Diaco had a trophy built for the series and announced it on Twitter. UCF had not been aware of it beforehand.[8][9][10] The Knights' head coach and interim athletic director George O'Leary dismissed both the trophy and the motivations for a rivalry between the two teams.[11] Diaco responded by saying, "They don't get to say whether they are our rival or not."[3][12] The New York Post said that Diaco created the "worst rivalry in sports history."[13]
The teams played three times during Diaco's tenure as head coach and twice following his announcement of the trophy. UConn won in 2014 and 2015. UCF won the 2016 game, and proceeded to exit the field without acknowledging or accepting the trophy.[14] The trophy was then purportedly crated and transported back to Connecticut. Following that game, Diaco said he was "shelving the venture".[15]
In 2016, UCF head coach Scott Frost asked UConn not to bring the trophy and that UCF was officially opting out of the rivalry game. UConn elected to ignore Frost's request and brought the trophy to the 2016 game anyway. UCF went on to beat UConn that year 24–16, however the UCF team did not claim the trophy and it was left unattended on the UCF sideline after the game.[2] Diaco was fired as head coach of UConn at the end of the 2016 season after an 11–26 record over his three seasons as head coach; Randy Edsall, who replaced Diaco, elected to not continue the supposed rivalry.[16] After leaving UConn, Diaco stated that UCF knew about the Conflict and they had been engaged prior to the announcement of the rivalry by UConn.[citation needed] UConn women's basketball head coach Geno Auriemma said the rivalry "might have been the dumbest thing in the history of sports."[6]
UConn Athletic Director David Benedict, who himself never officially acknowledged the rivalry or the trophy, was asked in 2017 about the trophy's whereabouts. He replied, "I honestly don't know. That trophy was there before I got there. I believe that trophy was commissioned and paid for by coach Diaco. And therefore if it left with him, I don't know that, but if it did that's fine."[17]
During the 2017 meeting in Orlando, the trophy and the claimed rivalry continued to be a subject of ridicule,[18][19] and the whereabouts of the original trophy were still unknown.[20]
On the eve of the 2021 matchup, UCF posted a video showing what was believed to be an "imposter" trophy on the field at the FBC Mortgage Stadium.[2][21][22]
^ abcVannini, Chris (November 9, 2023). "The search for the (real) Civil Conflict trophy, monument to a rivalry that never was". The Athletic. Orlando, Florida. Retrieved November 9, 2023. This summer, I set out to find the truth behind a modern college football legend. In the years since it disappeared, the idea of the rivalry and its trophy has evolved from a joke to a more earnest appreciation. UCF, which once mocked the idea of the trophy, is now happy to have it.