The album was recorded at the Trocadero Theatre, in the band's hometown of Philadelphia.[5] The Trocadero also served as the venue for the Dead Milkmen's first reunion show, in 2004, performed in honor of their late bass player, Dave Schulthise.[6]
The Tennessean wrote that the album "showcases the Milkmen at their anarchistic best."[11]Trouser Press called the album "a slapdash greatest-hits concert record," writing that "most of the renditions are surprisingly worse than the originals."[12]
AllMusic wrote that the songs "document the group's prime period, even if these versions don't quite compare to the originals."[7]