Bước nhảy hoàn vũ 2011 is the second season of Bước nhảy hoàn vũ produced by Vietnam Television and Cat Tien Sa Productions based upon the BBC Worldwide's Dancing with the Stars. The show encountered numerous changes, including a proposed reduction of the judging panel to the number of just three judges (three return), but was opposed and remained unchanged at four (two among them are new), the quitting of several cast members prior the launching and the departure of judges either before or during the show, a new co-host, new professionals as well as multiple changes in format written by the copyright holder from Bulgaria. The first show was aired on VTV3 with 10 celebrities. There was not an elimination the first two weeks of competition. The first took place on the third week (May 1).[1]
Only Khánh Thi and Chí Anh, two judges from the previous season and Thanh Bạch returned. Thanh Vân left the show involved in her pregnancy. Two directors, Nguyễn Quang Dũng and Lê Hoàng, claimed they had conflicts with timetables, so they could not remain with the show for ten episodes. It was officially announced that Trần Tiến and Đức Huy consecutively took the roles, respectively.[2][3][4][5][6]Ngô Thanh Vân was offered the female host role meanwhile executive producer Lại Văn Sâm was offered the fourth slot on the judging panel but both softly refused.[7][8] First season runner-up Đoan Trang was confirmed as co-host.[9] On May 11, Trần Tiến revealed his departure from the show and the producer put Quang Dũng back to the panel.[10][11]
Professionals Anna Silova and Tisho Gavrilov also returned for one more season.[12] Others were Aleksandar Vachev, Daniel Nikolov Denev, Lachezar Stefanov Todorov, Petyo Dimitrov Stoyanov, Petya Bozhidarova Dimitrova, Valeriya Nikolaeva Bozukova, Tsveta Krasimirova Tsocheva and Iva Ludmilova Grigorova.[13]Vũ Thu Minh was announced to be the second Dancing Queen with her partner, Lachezar Stefanov Todorov.
Controversies
Contestants
Huy Tran was one of the first person to edit Michael Jackson's song "Beat it" and made it famous. Phan Anh, Thủy Tiên, Vũ Thu Phương, and Trương Ngọc Tình were the first four faces to appear in the competition,[2] but right later two male celebrities confirmed they were no longer joining the cast members.[14] Afterwards, Thu Minh, Huy Khánh, Đại Nghĩa, Phạm Anh Khoa, Kim Hiền, Thanh Thúy and Vĩnh Thụy were confirmed to participate.[3][12][15] On March 29, Vĩnh Thụy withdrew from the competition.[16][17] Immediately, Hứa Vỹ Văn was chosen to replace and Nguyên Vũ was the last celebrity to join.[18]
Judges' acting roles
The departure of Trần Tiến has raised a lot controversial problems to Bước Nhảy Hoàn Vũ this year. Many journalists from notable daily newspapers and magazines (namely Tuổi Trẻ, Thanh Niên, VnExpress, etc.) accused the producers of ill preparing, organizing the show and forcing judges play acting roles in many different types of characteristics of judging on the panel (like easy-going, humour, fantastic, etc.)[19] like a color commentator rather than allowing them to naturally judge the performance from contestants.[20] The grading scale even restrictedly ranges from 7 up to 10;[21] in the case of Chí Anh (who did not hesitate assigning a 6 without explanation or comment to a contestant), he was immediately given a feedback by Host Thanh Bạch whether the grade was wrong.[22]
The jury were not given contracts to sign nor were they informed as to how much time they would spend on this competition. Director Lê Hoàng confirmed his involvement prior to the first week launched, but did not appear in the first week and left the following week to be replaced by musician Đức Huy.[23]
Elimination order
According to Người đưa tin, the withdrawal of Vĩnh Thụy was like a pre-show elimination because no one could be too fool to easily leave the highest rated show which helped them a lot to gain more fame and earn more money.[24] The pre-elimination was heavily promoted by the media.
Jury carried half weight of the total score, the other half weight by audience's messages... and we don't know who classified these messages... Producers revealed how much, we only knew right that much... Finally, everything is just simply in the script.
About the real cast member, step by step Vĩ Văn, Kim Hiền, Huy Khánh, Vũ Thu Phương, etc. were eliminated as audience thought. Hoàng Anh, who was Huy Khánh's ex-wife, used Facebook note for raising a tension with the producers after he was out of the race. She also reported Khánh said to their kid to watch Bước nhảy hoàn vũ on Sunday night prior to his elimination.[24][25] That seemed the producers played treat, particularly had rigged the show. Producers denied these claims as baseless stating that there was officially a company collecting and classifying messages, and the results were not to be revealed by producers alone without VTV's permission. Simultaneously, they refused to give any information about how Huy Khánh was sent home.[25] Under pressure, producers finally agreed to provide information about textgate and to clarify everything.[26]
Mimicking
On week 7, Thu Minh wowed the judging panel with her exotic dance concept. Later, she came out on top of the board with two 10s for Samba. The next Monday, it was revealed that the choreography and wardrobe she wore looked amazingly similar to those of Max Kozhevnikov and Yulia Zagoruychenko in the World Super Stars Dance Festival in 2006.[27] In sudden press reports earlier in the week, two main judges Khánh Thi and Chí Anh stated "mimicking is actually self mastering, is the creativity of Thu Minh and Lachezar".[28] Producers tried to help
Thu Minh, claiming it was not Thu Minh's fault, that the wardrobe was made from our set of designers' ideas and gave no comment about the choreography.[29]
Conflict
Khánh Thi was viewed as envious of Thủy Tiên for the latter's
sexy body language and her risky techniques used in performances. In press reports, she denied having any conflict with competitor Thủy Tiên, resulting in unfair marks.[30]
Timing violation
Every performance should be performed in one and a half minutes according to standard practices in almost all versions Dancing with the Stars and in international competitions. The length of Thu Minh's performance was deemed the longest and the shortest performance was that of Đại Nghĩa with only 1 minute 40 seconds. Thu Minh was crowned the winner.[31] Once again in the week 9 and in the finale, Thu Minh and Lacho had additional performances.
Textgate
During week 9, there was additional controversy the week couple Anh Khoa and Iva were voted off. Some voters claimed that they could not send messages voting for Anh Khoa during textgate open, when received confirmatory text "Vui lòng nhắn tin bình chọn sau khi các thí sinh đã tham gia xong phần thi của mình. Xin chân thành cảm ơn" (literally: "Text after all performances done. Thank you for voting"). It is not clear if the "Thank you for voting" messages were incorrectly assigned, as if the replies were incorrectly assigned, votes would have been counted for the correct contestant despite the voters receiving the wrong "thank you" messages.[32][33]
All involved including the broadcaster, producers and textgate owner informed no errors during week 9 (June 26) in public press. They also revealed the out of phase of the text-gate with live audience which meant people could only text formally from 30 seconds up to a minute in normal mode after the announcement of hosts and clearly voting could be continued during short time when the gate was deemed closed.[33]
Unfair scores
In the case of Anh Khoa and Iva, all four judges gathered for quick break for discussion about giving scores.[34]
They are harshly criticized for giving generous scores very sentimentally based upon the case that contestants or partners' sickness, family's bad luck, not so serious injury and so on from the very first beginning of season 1 onwards.
No live shows in Ho Chi Minh City, No international winners
In public press released for pre-production, there would exist many live shows in Ho Chi Minh City and other live shows in Vũng Tàu as producers informed.[9] Later, Hanoi was offered 1-2 live shows for premiere weeks. Actually after the series ended, audience in HCMC had none show to enjoy. One of judges explained clearly bad organization and a bunch of controversies let Department of Culture, Sports and Tourism of Ho Chi Minh City not allow the show to arrive at HCMC.[34]
Also, no winners from China Mainland, Indonesia, Finland came performing.[15]
Finale crowning
Again and again, voting problem raised tension. Few voters affirmed that there was no message responded even 7 hours later.[35] It is generally agreed Thu Minh deserved the win for her spectacular and outstanding Rumba and Freestyle routines engraving two highest scores to the show's history and praised by the most talented former dancing couple Khánh Thi and Chí Anh. People, whereas, wondered themselves why Thủy Tiên previously determined the favourite competitor of the year had fewer votes and why audience backed out at her.[35] No official statement was made.
With 79 [with judges] and the percentage of votes is 46.02, scores 4 [in total]... the runner-up is Thủy Tiên
Besides that, there was much discussion in the communication industry about the real winner because there was confusion over the crowning. Initially, Đoan Trang revealed the runner-up, thus the other was the winner. Trang announced 79 scored by the runner-up. Moments that turned Thủy Tiên (who obviously scored 77) to the edge of glory and turned Thu Minh (who truly scored 79 out of possible 80) slightly blue was quickly stopped with the real name "Thủy Tiên", leading everyone got shocked.[36][37] As interpreted, mistakes was caused by result paper.[26][37]
Ngô Thanh Vân finale involvement
Many fans of first season winner, Ngô Thanh Vân, were upset that she did not take part in the whole new season, especially season finale. Executive producer Lương Minh responded in an interview with Dân Trí: "We have invited her to season finale as guest; however, she refused to attend because of being busy [going to America]. As she showed agreement, we could not change the schedule set because Tisho, her former partner doesn't have enough time [...] and the show's length doesn't allow us to do so. [...] Maybe she can join many next season finales".[38] Asked Thanh Vân, "Uhm... due to some reasons... tomorrow I can't be in BNHV... Everyone... [I] don't know what to say... please don't go sorrow...!!!"[39] She also mentioned, "I am always ready to serve when invited; however, at the time, I give no comments".[38]
Bước nhảy hoàn vũ: The Striptease Show
Tendency of peeling clothes (undressing) on stage was up gradually, beginning in the first week and accumulating in the finale. It is more focused on the "tease" in "striptease" than the "strip". At least six peeling actions were performed namely by Thu Minh, Valeriya and Đại Nghĩa, Kim Hiền, Vũ Thu Phương and Hồ Ngọc Hà herself.[40] These actions are considered over-sexy, seductive and influence the culture in a bad manner.
Red numbers indicate the lowest score for each week.
Green numbers indicate the highest score for each week.
Underlined numbers indicate the favorite contestant of the week
indicates the winning couple.
indicates the runner-up couple.
indicates the third-place couple.
indicates the couple eliminated that week.
indicates the returning couple that finished in the bottom two.
indicates the returning couple that was the last to be called safe (they may or may have not been in the bottom two).
Week 2: The competition officially kicked off. Musician Đức Huy joined the judging panel in replacement with Lê Hoàng. Thu Minh & Lachezar and Thanh Thúy & Aleksandar gained the best scores, were in tie at the first place with 36⁄40 for English Waltz and Cha-Cha-Cha, respectively. Kim Hiền & Daniel landed into the bottom with 30⁄40 for their Cha-Cha-Cha.
Week 3: Despite suffering from Chickenpox (so did Kim Hiền), Anh Khoa & Iva performed quite well and came out on top of the leader board with 38⁄40 including two first 10s of the season for their Bulgarian folk dance. In combination with Week 2, they had the best score. Vĩ Văn & Anna's ill performance led them to be eliminated. This was also the last week, Trần Tiến judged the show.
Week 4: After Trần Tiến's departure from the show, Nguyễn Quang Dũng was confirmed be back this season. Luchezar Stefanov Todorov did not team up with Thu Minh because of Chickenpox and he is alternated by Ngô Minh Đức, the very first Vietnamese professional to join Bước nhảy hoàn vũ. Thu Minh & Ngô Minh Đức were at top of the leaderboard with four 9s (36⁄40). Kim Hiền & Daniel received 31⁄40 for their Quickstep and were subsequently sent home.
Week 5: Lachezar returned and helped Thu Minh score at 35⁄40, including one 10 from Khánh Thi. Thanh Thúy & Aleks' performance received 38⁄40 with two 10s and were at top of the leaderboard. In spite of not having the least score, Huy Khánh & Tsveta were eliminated.
Week 6: Thu Minh & Lachezar once again were on top with 38⁄40, including two 10s for their Paso doble. Thanh Thúy & Aleksandar came second with 37⁄40 including one 10 for their Foxtrot. As a result, Vũ Thu Phương & Tisho were eliminated after landing to the bottom two three times in a row.
Week 7: With two 10s from judges for their Samba, Thu Minh & Lachezar came out on top of the leaderboard with 37⁄40, meanwhile Thanh Thúy & Aleks and Anh Khoa & Iva received the least scores for their worst Samba. As a result, Đại Nghĩa & Valeriya were sent home.
Week 8: Aleksandar got leg-injured during rehearsal. Thanh Thúy let the nerve turn her down and send her package home.
Week 9: Every single couple scored at least one 10 for their performance. Anh Khoa and Iva had a worse performance, leading them land to bottom two and be sent home.
Week 10 - Finale: First time in history, 40 was scored and there were two 40s assigned consecutively by Thu Minh & Lacho for the Rumba and by Thủy Tiên & Petyo for Freestyle. Ultimately, Thu Minh was crowned the Dancing Queen.
Highest and lowest scoring performances
The best and worst performances in each dance according to the judges' marks are as follows:
The season premiere included some special performances from guests, judges, professionals and competitors. The main competition kicks off in the following week.
Performers: Hồ Trung Dũng, Tiêu Châu Như Quỳnh, Dương Ánh Linh
Guest(s): Nguyễn Ngọc Anh, violist Trần Quang Duy
Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Trần Tiến - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive.
Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Trần Tiến - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive. It is the last week that Trần Tiến joins the judging panel.
Performers: Hồ Trung Dũng, Tiêu Châu Như Quỳnh, Lê Kim Ngân
Guest(s): Minh Quân, professional Ngô Minh Đức
Nguyễn Quang Dũng prominently takes his role back after Trần Tiến's announcing his departure. Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Nguyễn Quang Dũng - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive.
Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Nguyễn Quang Dũng - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive.
Performers: Hồ Trung Dũng, Tiêu Châu Như Quỳnh & Lê Kim Ngân
Guest(s): Doreen Fernandez from the Philippines
Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Nguyễn Quang Dũng - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive.
Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Nguyễn Quang Dũng - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive.
Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Nguyễn Quang Dũng - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive.
Performers: Hồ Trung Dũng, Dương Ánh Linh, Tiêu Châu Như Quỳnh & Tuyết Mai
Guest(s): Tiêu Châu Như Quỳnh, Minh Hằng
Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Nguyễn Quang Dũng - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive.
Individual judges scores in charts below (given in parentheses) are listed in this order from left to right: Nguyễn Quang Dũng - Khánh Thi - Đức Huy - Chí Anh. The results of the voting is combined with the ranking of the panel of judges, and the celebrities have the higher scores in total survive.