The club was established in 1891,[1] and later joined the West Sussex League. They won the Division Two title in 1972–73 and went on to win Division One the following season.[2] Following relegation the club won the Tony Kopp Cup and the Division Three North in 1979–80 and then Division Two North in 1982–83.[2] They were Division Two North champions again in 1992–93, before winning Division Three Central in 1998–99 and Division Two North in 2006–07.[2]
In 2010–11 Billingshurst won the Centenary Cup with a 2–1 victory over Newtown Villa in the final.[3] After winning the Malcolm Simmonds Memorial Cup and the Premier Division title in 2011–12,[2][4] the club moved up to Division Three of the Sussex County League,[5] which was renamed Division Two when the league became the Southern Combination in 2015.[5] In 2015–16 they finished fifth,[5] earning promotion to Division One.