Betfair Pty Limited v Western Australia

Betfair v WA

Court	High Court of Australia
Full case name	Betfair Pty Limited v Western Australia
Decided	27 March 2008
Citations	[2008] HCA 11, (2008) 234 CLR 418; 244 ALR 32
Court membership
Judges sitting	Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Kirby, Hayne, Heydon, Crennan and Kiefel JJ
Case opinions
(7:0) The 2007 amendments to Betting Control Act 1954 (WA) which prevented interstate betting exchange operators from conducting business in Western Australia were invalid under s 92 of the Australian Constitution

Betfair Pty Limited v Western Australia^[1] determined that a series of amendments made by the Western Australian government to prohibit the operation of betting exchanges,^[2] amounted to discriminatory burdens of a protectionist kind.

Background

The first plaintiff, Betfair Pty Ltd, operated a national betting exchange licensed in Tasmania and operated legally under Tasmanian law. Betfair’s exchange operated similarly to that of typical betting exchanges: Betfair would match the wagers of ‘registered players’ betting on opposing outcomes of sporting events either by telephone or through an online exchange, and then take a commission of the winner’s payout.

The amended Act placed three restrictions on the plaintiffs. Firstly, under the newly inserted s 27B(1) it would be illegal for Betfair, the first plaintiff (the ‘out-of-state supply’), to operate a betting exchange in Western Australia. Secondly, under the newly inserted s 24(1)aa of the Act, it would be illegal for residents of Western Australia, such as Mr. Erceg, the second plaintiff (the ‘in-state demand’ ), to place a wager through a betting exchange. Furthermore, under the newly inserted ss 27C and 27D of the Act, it would be also illegal to publish the race fields of Western Australian races without ministerial approval.^[2]

These new provisions of the Betting Control Act 1954 (WA) effectively prevented Betfair from participating in the Western Australian ‘wagering market’, a market dominated by Western Australian bookmakers and totalisators. Betfair argued that these amendments, namely ss 24(1aa) and 27D were invalid under s 92 of Constitution,^[3] as the amendments imposed ‘discriminatory burdens of a protectionist kind’. Section 24(1aa) prevented Betfair from competing for telephone and online gamblers.^[2] Betfair was the only betting operator out of 115 which did not receive ministerial approval under Section 27D, and was therefore prevented from publishing the fields of Western Australian races.

The defendants submitted that these provisions, although discriminatory, were not used for the purpose of protectionism but rather for legitimate non-protectionist purposes. In addition to threatening an industry where Betfair made no contribution, the introduction of a betting exchange, where it was possible to ‘back to lose’, presented a risk that users may attempt to influence the outcome of a race and threaten the integrity of the racing industry.

Decision

The High Court held unanimously that the Western Australian government did indeed establish discriminatory burdens of a protectionist kind, and declared the amendments invalid under Section 92 of the Constitution of Australia.^[1] Notably, the judgement distinguished the court's approach to proportionality under the Cole test, arguing that trade-restrictive legislation must be 'reasonably necessary', not justified merely in balancing out a social or economic detriment.^[4]

References

^ ^a ^b Betfair Pty Limited v Western Australia [2008] HCA 11, (2008) 234 CLR 418 (27 March 2008), High Court (Australia).
^ ^a ^b ^c Betting and Racing Legislation Amendment Act 2006 (WA).
^ Constitution (Cth) s 92 Trade within the Commonwealth to be free.
^ "Betfair Pty Ltd v Western Australia [2008] HCA 11 - BarNet Jade". jade.io. Retrieved 15 June 2022.

Read other articles:

Dallas Mavericks

Dallas MavericksDallas Mavericks musim 2023–24WilayahBaratDivisiBarat DayaDibentuk1980SejarahDallas Mavericks1980–sekarang[1][2]ArenaAmerican Airlines CenterLetakDallas, TexasWarna timBiru royal, biru laut, perak, hitam[3][4] Sponsor utamaChime[5]Manajer umumNico HarrisonPelatih kepalaJason KiddPemilikMark CubanAfiliasiTexas LegendsJuara1 (2011)Gelar Wilayah2 (2006, 2011)Gelar Divisi3 (1987, 2007, 2010)Nomor yang dipensiunk...

Banjar, Licin, Banyuwangi

BanjarDesaKantor Desa BanjarPeta lokasi Desa BanjarNegara IndonesiaProvinsiJawa TimurKabupatenBanyuwangiKecamatanLicinKode pos68454Kode Kemendagri35.10.24.2004 Luas4,36 km²Jumlah penduduk2.511 jiwaKepadatan576 jiwa/km² Banjar adalah sebuah nama desa di wilayah Licin, Kabupaten Banyuwangi, Provinsi Jawa Timur, Indonesia. Desa ini memiliki tagline bertajuk Banjar Sweet Village. Desa Banjar memiliki kuliner khas Sego lemeng dan Kopi uthek Pembagian wilayah Desa Banjar terdiri dari 4 dusun...

Gustaf Retzius

Swedish histologist (1842–1919) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Gustaf Retzius – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (November 2017) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Gustaf RetziusGustaf RetziusBorn17 October 1842[1]Stockholm[1]Died21 July 1919(19...

Lincoln Red Imps F.C. 1–0 Celtic F.C.

Historic win of Lincoln Red Imps against Celtic in 2016 Football matchLincoln Red Imps 1–0 CelticAerial view of Victoria Stadium, GibraltarEvent2016–17 UEFA Champions League second qualifying round – First leg Lincoln Red Imps Celtic 1 0 Date12 July 2016 (2016-07-12)VenueVictoria Stadium, GibraltarRefereeAndreas Ekberg (Sweden)Attendance1,632 Lincoln Red Imps vs Celtic was a football match played on 12 July 2016 at Victoria Stadium, Gibraltar. The match was a UEFA Champio...

PS-28 Khairpur-III

Constituency of the Provincial Assembly of Sindh, Pakistan PS-28 Khairpur-IIIConstituencyfor the Provincial Assembly of SindhRegionThari Mirwah Taluka (partly) and Nara Tehsil (partly) of Khairpur DistrictElectorate207,136 [1]Current constituencyMember(s)VacantCreated fromPS-33 Khairpur-V PS-28 Khairpur-III (پی ایس-28، خیرپور-3) is a constituency of the Provincial Assembly of Sindh.[2][3] Sajid Ali Banbhan elected as MPA of Thari Mirwah Nara on 2024-8 Feb. ...

2000 Big Ten men's basketball tournament

College basketball tournament 2000 Big Ten men's basketball tournamentClassificationDivision ISeason1999–00Teams11SiteUnited CenterChicago, IllinoisChampionsMichigan State Spartans (2nd title)Winning coachTom Izzo (2nd title)MVPMorris Peterson (Michigan State)TelevisionESPN Plus, ESPN2, CBSBig Ten men's basketball tournaments← 19992001 → 1999–2000 Big Ten Conference men's basketball standings vte Conf Overall Team W L PCT W L ...

The Amazing Race Canada

Canadian adventure reality game show For the upcoming season, see The Amazing Race Canada 10. The Amazing Race CanadaThe title card used since season 3GenreReality competitionCreated byElise DoganieriBertram van MunsterBased onThe Amazing Raceby Bertram van MunsterElise DoganieriCreative directorShannon McGinnPresented byJon MontgomeryTheme music composerJohn M. KeaneCountry of originCanadaOriginal languageEnglishNo. of seasons9No. of episodes100 (and 1 recap and 6 reunion specials)Production...

Chiangrai United F.C.

Association football club in Thailand Football clubChiangrai United เชียงราย ยูไนเต็ดFull nameChiangrai United Football Club สโมสรฟุตบอลเชียงราย ยูไนเต็ดNickname(s)The Beetles (กว่างโซ้งมหาภัย)Short nameCRUTDFounded2009; 15 years ago (2009)GroundLeo Chiangrai StadiumChiang Rai, ThailandCapacity11,354PresidentMiti TiyapairatHead coachGabriel MagalhãesLeagueThai...

Gravitational wave

Propagating spacetime ripple This article is about the phenomenon of general relativity. For the movement of classical fluids, see Gravity wave. Simulation of the collision of two black holes. In addition to forming deep gravity wells and coalescing into a single larger black hole, gravitational waves will propagate outwards as the black holes spin past each other. General relativity G μ ν + Λ g μ ν = κ T μ ν {\displaystyle G_{\mu \nu }+...

Paweł Franczak

Polish bicycle racer Paweł FranczakFranczak at the 2016 Grand Prix de DenainPersonal informationFull namePaweł FranczakBorn (1991-10-07) 7 October 1991 (age 32)Nysa, PolandHeight1.78 m (5 ft 10 in)Weight63 kg (139 lb)Team informationCurrent teamRetiredDisciplineRoadRoleRiderProfessional teams2013Team Wibatech–Brzeg2014–2016ActiveJet2017Team Hurom2018CCC–Sprandi–Polkowice[1]2019–2021Voster ATS Team[2][3] Paweł Francza...

Золотой глобус (премия, 1949)

6-я церемония вручения наград премии «Золотой глобус» 16 марта 1949 Лучший фильм : «Джонни Белинда» «Сокровища Сьерра-Мадре» 6-я церемония вручения наград премии «Золотой глобус» за заслуги в области кинематографа за 1948 год. Церемония была проведена 16 марта 1949 года в Лос-�...

Sasolit

SasolitSasolit kuningUmumKategoriMineral boratRumus(unit berulang)H3BO3Klasifikasi Strunz06.AA.05Sistem kristalTriklinik-pinakoidalGrup ruangTriklinik 1Sel unita = 7,02 Å, b = 7,06 Å, c = 6,59 Å; α = 103,65°, β = 101,11°, γ = 59,98°; Z = 4IdentifikasiWarnaPutih hingga abu-abu, mungkin berwarna kuning pucat dari belerang atau cokelat pucat dari besi oksida; tidak berwarna dalam cahaya yang ditransmisikanPerawakanSebagai kristal bersisik pseudoheksagonal; penum...

Fred 2: Night of the Living Fred

2011 film This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Fred 2: Night of the Living Fred – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (April 2024) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Fred 2: Night of the Living FredDVD cover of the movieDirected byJohn FortenberryWritten byDavid A. GoodmanBased on...

Chojoongdong

Term for major South Korean newspapers ChojoongdongHangul조중동Hanja朝中東Revised RomanizationJojungdongMcCune–ReischauerChojungdong This article is part of a series onConservatismin South Korea Schools Authoritarian Ilminism Corporate Cultural Fiscal Libertarian Moderate Conservatism Liberal Conservatism Economic Liberalism Welfare State Paternalistic Warm Conservatism Progressive Conservatism Populist State-aligned nationalism Social Traditional Hongik Ingan neo-Confucian Principles...

1790 Footprints

East Hawaiʻi Battles of 1790Part of Unification of HawaiiAsh layer from 1790 eruption.Date1790LocationEastern Hawaiʻi IslandResult inconclusiveBelligerents Kamehameha I's army Keōua KuahuʻulaCommanders and leaders Kamehameha IKeawemauhili Keōua Kuahuʻula vteUnification of Hawaiʻi Mokuʻōhai Olowalu Kaʻūpūlehu Kepaniwai East Hawaiʻi Kawaihae Kawela Nuʻuanu Namakeha's rebellion Kauaʻi United States historic place1790 FootprintsU.S. National Register of Historic Places Location9.1 ...

كأس الكونكاكاف الذهبية 2015

2015 تفاصيل البطولة الدولة المستضيفة الولايات المتحدة كندا المدن 14 المنظم كونكاكاف التاريخ يوليو 7–26 الفرق Qualified teams الأماكن Venues (في 14 المدن المستضيفة) البطل منتخب المكسيك لكرة القدم إحصائيات البطولة عدد المباريات 24 عدد الأهداف 56 (2.33 لكل مباراة) الحضور 1...

العلاقات الفيجية اللاوسية

العلاقات الفيجية اللاوسية فيجي لاوس فيجي لاوس تعديل مصدري - تعديل العلاقات الفيجية اللاوسية هي العلاقات الثنائية التي تجمع بين فيجي ولاوس.[1][2][3][4][5] مقارنة بين البلدين هذه مقارنة عامة ومرجعية للدولتين: وجه المقارنة فيجي لاوس المساحة (�...

West Milford, New Jersey

Township in Passaic County, New Jersey, US West Milford redirects here. For the town in West Virginia, see West Milford, West Virginia. See also: Milford, New Jersey and New Milford, New Jersey Township in New Jersey, United StatesWest Milford, New JerseyTownshipMuseum at Long Pond Ironworks SealMotto: A Clean CommunityLocation of West Milford in Passaic County highlighted in yellow (left). Inset map: Location of Passaic County in New Jersey highlighted in black (right).Census Bureau map...

2007 Isle of Man TT

2007 Isle of Man TT RacesIsle of Man TT Mountain Course layoutRace detailsDate26 May – 8 June 2007LocationDouglas, Isle of ManCourseIsle of Man TT Mountain Course 37.73 mi / 60.20 kmSenior TT Pole Position Fastest Lap John McGuinness John McGuinness 129.085 mph 130.354 mph Podium 1. John McGuinness2. Guy Martin3. Ian Hutchinson Junior TT 600 cc Pole Position Fastest Lap John McGuinness Guy Martin 122.423 mph 125.161 mph Podium 1. Ian Hu...

Glove

Covering worn on the hand For other uses, see Glove (disambiguation). GloveAssorted gloves (a museum collection)Typehand's protection A glove is a garment covering the hand, with separate sheaths or openings for each finger including the thumb.[1] Gloves protect and comfort hands against cold or heat, damage by friction, abrasion or chemicals, and disease; or in turn to provide a guard for what a bare hand should not touch. Gloves are made of materials including cloth, knitted or felt...