Many of Benchley's residents left because of the runaway scrape, which occurred between September 1835 and April 1836.[3]
Around the 1840s, a band of criminals posed as preachers, and while one gave a sermon, the others attempted to make off with several horses. Residents went after them, and some of the thieves were killed. The residents were then able to get back their horses.[3]
Throughout its history, the community has never had more than just a few businesses or public locations.[3]
Government services
Benchley lies within the boundaries of the Bryan ISD, and Brazos County Pct. 4 Fire Department in Brazos County, and Blackjack Volunteer Fire Department in Robertson County. Benchley is served by the Bryan post office with the Bryan, TX zip code 77807.