The cottage was built circa 1837, shortly after Samuel and Robert Patterson acquired the land.[3] In 1847, it was acquired by John Coulson, a merchant.[3] When Coulson purchased the Cliffs Plantation from John W. Henderson in 1868, Henderson in turn purchased Belvidere.[3]
The house was moved northwards in 1927, when the Margaret Martin Junior High School was built where it once stood.[3]
By 1980, it still belonged to the Henderson family.[3]