He was Los Angeles city attorney in 1872โ76 and a judge of the Los Angeles County Superior Court.[2] In August 1898, he was chairman of a rally at Hazard's Pavilion on behalf of James G. Maguire, candidate for governor of California.[4]
In 1904 Hutton was chairman of a specially appointed jury that heard charges by real estate developer and fruit grower Abbot Kinney against A. H. Naftzger. president of the California Fruit Agency and nominal head of the Southern California Fruit Exchange. He filed a 15-page dissent against the acquittal of Naftzger.[5]
He died at the age of 86 on January 11, 1934, in his home, 1704 Ocean View Avenue, Santa Monica. He was survived by his six children.[2] His oldest son, Aurelius W. Hutton Jr. had died in 1895 at the age of 19.[6]