In 1863, a constitutional amendment meant all of the seats of the Supreme Court of California were open for election.[5] In October 1863, Rhodes was elected to the Supreme Court of California, and served from January 2, 1864, until 1880.[6][7] He served as the 10th Chief Justice from 1870 to 1872.[8][9][10][11] His first term expired January 1, 1872, and the Court referred the issue of whether he would continue to serve as Chief Justice to a panel of three San Francisco attorneys.[12] They decided that Article 6, Section 3, of the 1862 state Constitution required the justice with the shortest remaining term to serve, and so Royal Sprague replaced Rhodes as chief justice.[12] In October 1871, Rhodes was elected to a ten-year term.[13] A new Constitution adopted in 1879 required elections for all Supreme Court positions. In 1879, he ran for Chief Justice but lost to Robert F. Morrison.[14][15]
From 1899 to 1907, he served as a Superior Court judge in Santa Clara County.[16][17][18] The vacancy on the trial bench caused by Rhodes's retirement (at the age of 88) was filled by John E. Richards.[19]
Rhodes remained active to an advanced age; he gave an address at the annual convention of the California Bar Association in June 1918, four months before his death at the age of 97.[20]
Personal life
On September 30, 1846, Rhodes married Elizabeth Greene Cavins (April 7, 1829 – December 25, 1901),[21] a judge's daughter in Greene County, Indiana.[22] They had six children: Mary Rhodes (Barstow) (born 1848), who married the son of her father's law partner;[23] James H. Rhodes (born 1849); Samuel R. Rhodes (born 1854), who became a doctor;[24] Margaret Rhodes (1857-1870); Edward Livingston Rhodes (1860-1945), who joined his father's law firm of Rhodes & Barstow after graduating from the University of California, Berkeley, and later served as a justice of the peace in Chino, California;[25][24][26] and Augusta E. Rhodes (born 1868).[22]
^"Will Honor Judge Rhodes". San Francisco Call. Vol. 96, no. 25. California Digital Newspaper Collection. June 25, 1904. p. 2. Retrieved July 10, 2017. In 1859 he was elected District Attorney in this county, and in 1860 was elected State Senator to represent Santa Clara and Alameda counties.
^"The Supreme Court". San Francisco Call. Library of Congress, Chronicling America. June 22, 1895. p. 5. Retrieved July 18, 2017. Under the constitutional provision, on October 21, 1863, Oscar L. Shafter, Lorenzo Sawyer, Silas W. Sanderson, John Curry and A. L. Rhodes were elected Supreme Court Justices. The new court organized January 2, 1864, and in accordance with law, the Judges drew lots to determine the tenure of their official terms, with the following result: Shafter drew for ten years, Rhodes for eight. Sawyer for six, Curry for four and Sanderson for two.
^ ab"Our Judicial Election". Sacramento Daily Union. Vol. 44, no. 6932. California Digital Newspaper Collection. June 21, 1873. p. 4. Retrieved July 10, 2017. At the expiration of the first term of Chief Justice Rhodes, January 1st, 1872.
^"The State Judicial Elections". Daily Alta California. Vol. 25, no. 8596. California Digital Newspaper Collection. October 11, 1873. p. 2. Retrieved July 9, 2017. Justice Rhodes, elected in 1871, to retire in 1881.
^"The Supreme Bench: Vote Returns". Tocsin. No. 50. California Digital Newspaper Collection. October 4, 1879. p. 3. Retrieved July 9, 2017.
^Uelmen, Gerald F. (1988). "California Judicial Retention Elections". Santa Clara Law Review. 28 (2): 333–377, 335. Retrieved July 10, 2017. Table 1, Incumbent Justices Defeated for Reelection, 1880, August Rhodes defeated by Robert Morrison.
^"Judge Rhodes to be Banqueted". San Francisco Call. Vol. 96, no. 9. California Digital Newspaper Collection. June 9, 1904. p. 3. Retrieved July 10, 2017.
^"Judge Richards Installed". San Francisco Call. No. 102. California Digital Newspaper Collection. September 12, 1907. p. 7. Retrieved July 18, 2017.
^Proceedings of the annual convention, California Bar Association, volume 9, 1918
^ ab"The Day's Dead". San Francisco Call. Vol. 91, no. 26. California Digital Newspaper Collection. December 26, 1901. p. 9. Retrieved July 18, 2017.
^"Want a Deed". Evening Sentinel. Vol. 3, no. 65. California Digital Newspaper Collection. August 16, 1898. p. 3. Retrieved July 18, 2017.
^ ab"Leap Year Orange Blossoms". Sacramento Daily Union. Vol. 58, no. 135. California Digital Newspaper Collection. January 26, 1888. p. 3. Retrieved July 18, 2017.
^"Late Telegrams". Los Angeles Herald. Vol. 15, no. 147. California Digital Newspaper Collection. July 29, 1881. p. 1. Retrieved July 18, 2017.