She played Lady Jane in the Off-Broadway musical version of The Prince and the Pauper from 2002 to 2003, and briefly performed at Playwrights Horizon in January 2003 in Jeanine Tesori's musical, Violet.[1]
In 2004 she was an understudy in the off-Broadway show Children's Letters to God.[2] The musical opened at the Lamb's Theatre on June 30, 2004,[3] and closed on January 2, 2005.[4]
In 2006 Fischer starred in the musical Lestat, playing Claudia in the Elton John and Bernie Taupin musical.[1] The musical was a flop, only running on Broadway from April 25 to May 28.[5] Fischer went on to play the role of Patty Simcox in the 2007 revival of Grease at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre.[1] She performed from its opening on August 19, 2007, until it closed on January 4, 2009.[6] Fischer also played Patty Simcox in the Broadway National Tour of Grease. Since then Fischer has been part of Yale's Musical Theatre Festival with the new musical "The Profit of Creation," sang back-up for Florence and The Machine, and was a part of several upcoming indie films.
On television, Allison Fischer played the role of Megan on the now defunct soap opera, Guiding Light.[7]