In May 2022, Newman joined expansion club Sydney.[10] The speedy small forward played 9 games for the club in the inaugural AFLW season as its most experienced player, becoming the first Indigenous AFLW player at each of her three clubs.[11]
In round two of the 2023 season, Newman played her 50th AFLW game when she booted an equal career-high 3 goals against Geelong at North Sydney Oval.[12] She continued to be a regular in the forward line, playing 10 games for the season including kicking a goal in each of the club's first two finals appearances.[1] Newman also designed the Swans' first ever Indigenous Round guernsey unique to AFLW in 2023.[13]