This is a list of college baseball players named first team All-Americans for the 2016 NCAA Division I baseball season. The NCAA recognizes four different All-America selectors for baseball: the American Baseball Coaches Association (since 1947), Baseball America (since 1981), Collegiate Baseball (since 1991), and the National Collegiate Baseball Writers Association (since 2001).^[1]

Position	Name	School	ABCA	BA	CB	NCBWA	Notes
Starting pitcher	Drew Harrington	Louisville	—	—	Y	Y	Atlantic Coast Conference Pitcher of the Year
Starting pitcher	Kevin Hill	South Alabama	—	—	Y	—	Sun Belt Conference Pitcher of Year
Starting pitcher	Connor Jones	Virginia	Y	—	—	Y
Starting pitcher	Eric Lauer*	Kent State	Y	Y	Y	Y	Mid-American Conference Pitcher of the Year National Pitcher of the Year Award winner[7]
Starting pitcher	Joey Lucchesi	Southeast Missouri State	—	—	Y	—	Ohio Valley Conference Pitcher of the Year
Starting pitcher	Kade McClure	Louisville	—	—	—	Y
Starting pitcher	A. J. Puckett*	Pepperdine	Y	Y	Y	—	West Coast Conference Pitcher of the Year
Starting pitcher	Cody Sedlock	Illinois	—	Y	—	—
Starting pitcher	Logan Shore*	Florida	Y	Y	Y	Y	Southeastern Conference Pitcher of the Year
Starting pitcher	Tyler Wilson	Rhode Island	Y	—	—	—
Relief pitcher	Shaun Anderson	Florida	—	—	—	Y
Relief pitcher	Zack Burdi	Louisville	—	—	—	Y
Relief pitcher	Sam Donko	Virginia Commonwealth	—	—	—	Y
Relief pitcher	Bryan Garcia	Miami	—	—	—	Y
Relief pitcher	Troy Rallings*	Washington	Y	Y	Y	Y	Pac-12 Conference Pitcher of the Year
Catcher	Zack Collins*	Miami	Y	Y	—	Y
Catcher	Nick Feight	UNC Wilmington	—	—	Y	—	Colonial Athletic Association Player of the Year
Catcher	Chris Okey	Clemson	—	—	—	Y
First baseman	Pete Alonso	Florida	—	—	—	Y
First baseman	Jameson Fisher	Southeastern Louisiana	Y	—	Y	—	Southland Conference Player of the Year
First baseman	Eric Gutierrez	Texas Tech	—	Y	—	—
Second baseman	Ryne Birk	Texas A&M	—	Y	—	—
Second baseman	Brian Mims	UNC Wilmington	Y	—	—	Y
Second baseman	Trey York	East Tennessee State	Y	—	—	—
Third baseman	Will Craig*	Wake Forest	Y	Y	—	Y	Baseball America chose Craig as a designated hitter[3]
Third baseman	Boomer White	Texas A&M	—	Y	—	—	Southeastern Conference Player of the Year
Shortstop	Sheldon Neuse	Oklahoma	—	—	—	Y	Brooks Wallace Award winner
Shortstop	C. J. Chatham	Florida Atlantic	Y	—	Y	—	Conference USA Player of the Year
Shortstop	Taylor Walls	Florida State	—	Y	—	—
Outfielder	Seth Beer†*	Clemson	Y	Y	Y	—	Atlantic Coast Conference Player of the Year,[3] Dick Howser Trophy winner
Outfielder	Alex Call	Ball State	—	—	Y	—	Mid-American Conference Player of the Year
Outfielder	Anfernee Grier	Auburn	—	Y	—	—
Outfielder	Kyle Lewis†*	Mercer	Y	Y	Y	—	Southern Conference Player of the Year Golden Spikes Award winner
Outfielder	Connor Owings	Coastal Carolina	Y	—	—	Y
Outfielder	Ryan Scott	Arkansas-Little Rock	Y	—	Y	—	Sun Belt Conference Player of Year
Outfielder	Corey Ray	Louisville	Y	—	—	Y
Utility player	Darick Hall	Dallas Baptist	—	—	Y	—	Missouri Valley Conference Player of the Year
Utility player	Brendan McKay*	Louisville	Y	Y	—	Y	John Olerud Award winner
Designated hitter	G. K. Young	Coastal Carolina	Y	—	—	Y

• College baseball awards