Gene Rossi threw 14-of-29 for 170 yards. The winning touchdown occurred on a fourth down punt. Punter Frank Wise moved under center and took the snap, lateraling to the right to quarterback Gene Mayfield. Mayfield completed a pass to Billy Cross at the Cincinnati 40 and Cross broke several tackles to finish the 62-yard touchdown dash. With the game running out, the Bearcats managed to get to the West Texas A&M 27, but two straight sacks doomed Cincinnati.[2]
Second Quarter
West Texas A&M - Bill Cross 4-yard run (Roy Lee Dunn Kick)
Cincinnati - Tom McKeever 3-yard run (kick failed)
Third Quarter
Cincinnati - Bob Stratton 17-yard pass from Gene Rossi (Bill Shalonsky kick)
West Texas A&M - Cross 62-yard pass from Gene Mayfield (Dunn kick)